commit 54146d9aa44a5b655d9ee002559bfc55893f9ecc Author: Bernhard Wally Date: Sun Apr 12 22:29:06 2020 +0200 The one and only commit. diff --git a/README.MD b/README.MD new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ed11de8 --- /dev/null +++ b/README.MD @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +# Support Material for "Leveraging Iterative Plan Refinement for Reactive Smart Manufacturing Systems" + +![DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3841121](https://zenodo.org/badge/DOI/10.5281/zenodo.3841121.svg "DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3841121") + +This repository contains supplemental resources for the T-ASE paper "Leveraging Iterative Plan Refinement for Reactive Smart Manufacturing Systems". Specifically, it provides detailed information about the mapping from IEC 62264 to PDDL: +* A small example with model fragments to [show how PDDL actions are created from IEC 62264 process segments](#creating-pddl-actions-from-iec-62264-process-segments). +* A [detailed explanation of IEC 62264 to PDDL mapping rules](#mapping-rules). +* A [complete set of IEC 62264 input models](#iec-62264-models). +* A [complete set of PDDL output files](#pddl-files). +* The [underlying metamodels](#metamodels). +* The [results](#results) from the evaluation runs. + +## Creating PDDL actions from IEC 62264 process segments +Excerpts from an IEC 62264 model that are relevant to generate a PDDL action from an IEC 62264 process segment. The example files are provided in the sub-folder [move-shuttle](move-shuttle). + +## Mapping Rules +A detailed guide to the mapping rules between IEC 62264 and PDDL that have been applied in the context of this paper are explained in the [README.MD](transformations/README.MD) in the sub-folder [transformations](transformations). + +## IEC 62264 Models +Full IEC 62264 model of the production system, as it is used in the paper, for the test-run with *one* product to be manufactured. The core IEC 62264 model that is used to generate the PDDL domain description as well as most parts of the PDDL problem file is provided in [iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.iec62264](iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.iec62264). The IEC 62264 model that describes the envisioned goal state of the production system and is used to generate the goal clause of the PDDL problem file is given in [iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-Goal-1.iec62264](iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-Goal-1.iec62264). + +## PDDL Files +The generated PDDL files are provided in sub-folder [pddl](pddl). The [domain](pddl/domain-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl) file is used together with the [problem](pddl/problem-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl) description to compute a [plan](pddl/plan-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl). The plan file itself is already a computed artifact returned from the PDDL solver, which in this use case was [FastDownward](http://www.fast-downward.org/). The following call can be used to re-create the plan file (potentially with a different sequence of actions). +``` +fast-downward.py --plan-file plan-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl domain-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE.pddl problem-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl --evaluator h1=ff --search eager_greedy([g,goalcount,cg,h1],[h1]) +``` + +## Metamodels +Full metamodels for IEC 62264 and for PDDL, as they have been used in the context of this paper, are provided in sub-folder [metamodels](metamodels). Both are defined using [Ecore](https://www.eclipse.org/modeling/emf/) as the meta-metamodel. + +## Results +Results of all evaluation runs (as tab-separated values) are provided in sub-folder [results](results). Nomenclature of the files is as follows: `out----.csv`. +Where `numOfProducts` is the number of products to be produced in one production run (from 1 to 7). `eagerInitial` states that the initial plan was searched for using an eager search algorithm (`true`) or a lazy one (`false`). `eagerForecast` is `true` if the forecasting service was realized using an eager search algorithm, otherwise `false`. `parallel` is `true` if the found plans are being parallelized a-posteriori, otherwise `false`. diff --git a/iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.iec62264 b/iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.iec62264 new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f903771 --- /dev/null +++ b/iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.iec62264 @@ -0,0 +1,1592 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-Goal-1.iec62264 b/iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-Goal-1.iec62264 new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8849828 --- /dev/null +++ b/iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-Goal-1.iec62264 @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/metamodels/iec62264.ecore b/metamodels/iec62264.ecore new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a3daea6 --- /dev/null +++ b/metamodels/iec62264.ecore @@ -0,0 +1,1254 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/metamodels/pddl.ecore b/metamodels/pddl.ecore new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d19fed6 --- /dev/null +++ b/metamodels/pddl.ecore @@ -0,0 +1,396 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/move-shuttle/move-shuttle.iec62264 b/move-shuttle/move-shuttle.iec62264 new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f65d7c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/move-shuttle/move-shuttle.iec62264 @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + diff --git a/move-shuttle/move-shuttle.pddl b/move-shuttle/move-shuttle.pddl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..67b50c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/move-shuttle/move-shuttle.pddl @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +(:types EquipmentClass Equipment) + +(:constants + EC_PositioningUnit - EquipmentClass + EC_TransportationNode - EquipmentClass + EC_Shuttle - EquipmentClass +) + +(:predicates + (EquipmentClassed ?E - Equipment ?C - EquipmentClass) + (TransportationNodeOccupied ?E - Equipment) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E - Equipment) + (TransportationNodeConnection ?F ?T - Equipment) + (EquipmentLocation ?E ?R - Equipment) +) + +(:functions + (total-cost) + (shuttle-time ?FROM ?TO - Equipment) +) + +(:action MoveShuttle + :parameters (?SHUTTLE ?FROM ?TO - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?SHUTTLE EC_Shuttle) + (or + (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_TransportationNode) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?FROM)) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_TransportationNode) (TransportationNodeOccupied ?FROM) + ) + (or + (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_TransportationNode) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?TO)) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_TransportationNode) + (not (TransportationNodeOccupied ?TO)) + ) + (TransportationNodeConnection ?FROM ?TO) + (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?FROM) + (not (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?TO)) + ) + :effect + (and + (not (TransportationNodeOccupied ?FROM)) + (TransportationNodeOccupied ?TO) + (increase (total-cost) (shuttle-time ?FROM ?TO)) + (not (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?FROM)) + (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?TO) + ) +) diff --git a/pddl/domain-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl b/pddl/domain-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..99d0f9a --- /dev/null +++ b/pddl/domain-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl @@ -0,0 +1,316 @@ +(define (domain CIIRC-Testbed-TASE) + + (:requirements :action-costs :typing :negative-preconditions :disjunctive-preconditions :equality) + + (:types PersonnelClass Person EquipmentClass Equipment MaterialClass MaterialDefinition MaterialLot) + + (:constants + PC_MaintenanceEngineer - PersonnelClass + EC_Shuttle - EquipmentClass + EC_Robot - EquipmentClass + EC_BaseplateCarrier - EquipmentClass + EC_PositioningUnit - EquipmentClass + EC_TransportationNode - EquipmentClass + MC_Body - MaterialClass + MC_Truck - MaterialClass + MC_Pickable - MaterialClass + MC_Baseplate - MaterialClass + MC_TruckComponent - MaterialClass + MC_Chassis - MaterialClass + MC_Cabin - MaterialClass + MD_StakeBed-White-White-White - MaterialDefinition + MD_Cabin-Silver - MaterialDefinition + MD_StakeBed-Black-Blue-White - MaterialDefinition + MD_Body-Dumper-Yellow - MaterialDefinition + MD_Dumper-White-Transparent-Yellow - MaterialDefinition + MD_Tank-Black-White-Black - MaterialDefinition + MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue - MaterialDefinition + MD_TruckBaseplate - MaterialDefinition + MD_Chassis-Black - MaterialDefinition + MD_Cabin-Yellow - MaterialDefinition + MD_Body-Tank-Black - MaterialDefinition + MD_Cabin-Blue - MaterialDefinition + MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue - MaterialDefinition + MD_Dumper-White-Silver-Silver - MaterialDefinition + MD_Body-Dumper-Silver - MaterialDefinition + MD_Chassis-White - MaterialDefinition + MD_Cabin-Transparent - MaterialDefinition + MD_Body-StakeBed-White - MaterialDefinition + MD_Tank-Black-Blue-Silver - MaterialDefinition + MD_Cabin-White - MaterialDefinition + MD_Body-Tank-Silver - MaterialDefinition + EC_Table - EquipmentClass + ) + + (:predicates + (PersonClassed ?P - Person ?C - PersonnelClass) + (EquipmentClassed ?E - Equipment ?C - EquipmentClass) + (MaterialClassed ?D - MaterialDefinition ?C - MaterialClass) + (MaterialDefined ?L - MaterialLot ?D - MaterialDefinition) + (MaterialLotClassed ?L - MaterialLot ?C - MaterialClass) + (RobotOccupied ?E - Equipment) + (TransportationNodeOccupied ?E - Equipment) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E - Equipment) + (RobotEnabled ?E - Equipment) + (TransportationNodeConnection ?F ?T - Equipment) + (EquipmentLocation ?E ?R - Equipment) + (ReachesTo ?R ?E - Equipment) + (MaterialLocation ?M - MaterialLot ?E - Equipment) + (MaterialRaw ?M - MaterialLot) + (DefinitionMountable ?M ?B - MaterialDefinition) + (ClassMountable ?M ?B - MaterialClass) + (Mounted ?M ?B - MaterialLot) + (MaterialLotAssembly ?W ?P - MaterialLot) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly ?W ?P - MaterialDefinition) + ) + + (:functions + (total-cost) + (shuttle-time ?FROM ?TO - Equipment) + ) + + (:action LockPositioningUnit + :parameters (?E - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?E EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?E)) + ) + :effect + (and + (increase (total-cost) 1) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E) + ) + ) + + (:action UnlockPositioningUnit + :parameters (?E - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?E EC_PositioningUnit) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E) + ) + :effect + (and + (increase (total-cost) 1) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?E)) + ) + ) + + (:action MoveShuttle + :parameters (?SHUTTLE ?FROM ?TO - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?SHUTTLE EC_Shuttle) + (or + (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_TransportationNode) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?FROM)) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_TransportationNode) (TransportationNodeOccupied ?FROM) + ) + (or + (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_TransportationNode) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?TO)) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_TransportationNode) + (not (TransportationNodeOccupied ?TO)) + ) + (TransportationNodeConnection ?FROM ?TO) + (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?FROM) + (not (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?TO)) + ) + :effect + (and + (not (TransportationNodeOccupied ?FROM)) + (TransportationNodeOccupied ?TO) + (increase (total-cost) (shuttle-time ?FROM ?TO)) + (not (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?FROM)) + (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?TO) + ) + ) + + (:action Pick + :parameters (?ROBOT ?CARRIER - Equipment ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE - MaterialLot ?SUBCARRIER - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?ROBOT EC_Robot) + (not (RobotOccupied ?ROBOT)) + (RobotEnabled ?ROBOT) + (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (MaterialLotClassed ?PICKABLE MC_Pickable) + (MaterialLotClassed ?BASEPLATE MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialRaw ?PICKABLE) + (MaterialLocation ?BASEPLATE ?CARRIER) + (Mounted ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE) + (not (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?ROBOT)) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_Table) + (and + (ReachesTo ?ROBOT ?CARRIER) + (= ?CARRIER ?SUBCARRIER) + ) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_Shuttle) + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?SUBCARRIER EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentLocation ?CARRIER ?SUBCARRIER) + (ReachesTo ?ROBOT ?SUBCARRIER) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?SUBCARRIER) + ) + ) + ) + :effect + (and + (RobotOccupied ?ROBOT) + (increase (total-cost) 5) + (not (Mounted ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE)) + (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?ROBOT) + ) + ) + + (:action Place + :parameters (?ROBOT ?CARRIER - Equipment ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE - MaterialLot ?SUBCARRIER - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?ROBOT EC_Robot) + (RobotOccupied ?ROBOT) + (RobotEnabled ?ROBOT) + (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (MaterialLotClassed ?PICKABLE MC_Pickable) + (MaterialLotClassed ?BASEPLATE MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialRaw ?PICKABLE) + (MaterialLocation ?BASEPLATE ?CARRIER) + (not (Mounted ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE)) + (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?ROBOT) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_Table) + (and + (ReachesTo ?ROBOT ?CARRIER) + (= ?CARRIER ?SUBCARRIER) + ) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_Shuttle) + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?SUBCARRIER EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentLocation ?CARRIER ?SUBCARRIER) + (ReachesTo ?ROBOT ?SUBCARRIER) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?SUBCARRIER) + ) + ) + ) + :effect + (and + (not (RobotOccupied ?ROBOT)) + (increase (total-cost) 5) + (Mounted ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE) + (not (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?ROBOT)) + ) + ) + + (:action Assemble + :parameters (?ROBOT ?CARRIER - Equipment ?PICKABLE ?BASE ?ASSEMBLY ?BASEPLATE - MaterialLot ?SUBCARRIER - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?ROBOT EC_Robot) + (RobotOccupied ?ROBOT) + (RobotEnabled ?ROBOT) + (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (MaterialLotClassed ?PICKABLE MC_Pickable) + (MaterialLotClassed ?BASE MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialLotClassed ?ASSEMBLY MC_Truck) + (MaterialLotClassed ?BASEPLATE MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialRaw ?PICKABLE) + (MaterialLocation ?BASEPLATE ?CARRIER) + (Mounted ?BASE ?BASEPLATE) + (or + (exists ( ?AMD - MaterialDefinition ?PMD - MaterialDefinition ?BMD - MaterialDefinition) + (and + (MaterialDefined ?ASSEMBLY ?AMD) + (MaterialDefined ?PICKABLE ?PMD) + (MaterialDefined ?BASE ?BMD) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly ?AMD ?PMD) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly ?AMD ?BMD) + (DefinitionMountable ?PMD ?BMD) + ) + ) + (exists ( ?PMC - MaterialClass ?BMC - MaterialClass ?AMD - MaterialDefinition ?PMD - MaterialDefinition ?BMD - MaterialDefinition) + (and + (MaterialDefined ?ASSEMBLY ?AMD) + (MaterialDefined ?PICKABLE ?PMD) + (MaterialDefined ?BASE ?BMD) + (MaterialClassed ?BMD ?BMC) + (MaterialClassed ?PMD ?PMC) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly ?AMD ?PMD) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly ?AMD ?BMD) + (ClassMountable ?PMC ?BMC) + ) + ) + ) + (not (exists (?A - MaterialLot) + (and + (not (= ?A ?ASSEMBLY) + ) + (MaterialLotAssembly ?A ?BASE) + ) + ) + ) + (not (exists (?BP - MaterialLot) + (and + (not (= ?BP ?BASEPLATE) + ) + (Mounted ?ASSEMBLY ?BP) + ) + ) + ) + (not (Mounted ?PICKABLE ?BASEPLATE)) + (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?ROBOT) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_Table) + (and + (ReachesTo ?ROBOT ?CARRIER) + (= ?CARRIER ?SUBCARRIER) + ) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?CARRIER EC_Shuttle) + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?SUBCARRIER EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentLocation ?CARRIER ?SUBCARRIER) + (ReachesTo ?ROBOT ?SUBCARRIER) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?SUBCARRIER) + ) + ) + ) + :effect + (and + (not (RobotOccupied ?ROBOT)) + (increase (total-cost) 5) + (Mounted ?PICKABLE ?BASE) + (not (MaterialRaw ?PICKABLE)) + (not (MaterialRaw ?BASE)) + (MaterialLotAssembly ?ASSEMBLY ?PICKABLE) + (MaterialLotAssembly ?ASSEMBLY ?BASE) + (Mounted ?ASSEMBLY ?BASEPLATE) + (MaterialLocation ?ASSEMBLY ?CARRIER) + (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?CARRIER) + (not (MaterialLocation ?PICKABLE ?ROBOT)) + ) + ) + + (:action RepairRobot + :parameters (?ENGINEER - Person ?ROBOT - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (PersonClassed ?ENGINEER PC_MaintenanceEngineer) + (EquipmentClassed ?ROBOT EC_Robot) + (not (RobotEnabled ?ROBOT)) + ) + :effect + (and + (RobotEnabled ?ROBOT) + (increase (total-cost) 99) + ) + ) +) diff --git a/pddl/plan-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl b/pddl/plan-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..10e0856 --- /dev/null +++ b/pddl/plan-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +(pick e_robot-2 e_table-2 ml_body-opentop-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-table-2 e_table-2) +(moveshuttle e_shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-io-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(pick e_robot-3 e_table-3 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_truckbaseplate-table-3 e_table-3) +(pick e_robot-1 e_table-1 ml_cabin-yellow-1 ml_truckbaseplate-table-1 e_table-1) +(lockpositioningunit e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(place e_robot-1 e_shuttle-1 ml_cabin-yellow-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(pick e_robot-10 e_shuttle-1 ml_cabin-yellow-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(moveshuttle e_shuttle-2 e_positioningunit-io-2 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-3) +(lockpositioningunit e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-3) +(place e_robot-3 e_shuttle-2 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-2 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-3) +(unlockpositioningunit e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-3) +(moveshuttle e_shuttle-2 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-3 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-2) +(lockpositioningunit e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-2) +(pick e_robot-1 e_shuttle-2 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-2 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-2) +(place e_robot-1 e_shuttle-1 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(place e_robot-2 e_shuttle-2 ml_body-opentop-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-2 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-2) +(pick e_robot-1 e_shuttle-2 ml_body-opentop-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-2 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-2) +(place e_robot-10 e_shuttle-1 ml_cabin-yellow-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(pick e_robot-10 e_shuttle-1 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(place e_robot-10 e_table-10 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_truckbaseplate-table-10 e_table-10) +(pick e_robot-10 e_shuttle-1 ml_cabin-yellow-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(assemble e_robot-10 e_table-10 ml_cabin-yellow-1 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_opentop-black-yellow-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-table-10 e_table-10) +(place e_robot-1 e_shuttle-1 ml_body-opentop-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(pick e_robot-10 e_shuttle-1 ml_body-opentop-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-shuttle-1 e_positioningunit-machiningcenter-1) +(assemble e_robot-10 e_table-10 ml_body-opentop-blue-1 ml_chassis-black-1 ml_opentop-black-yellow-blue-1 ml_truckbaseplate-table-10 e_table-10) +; cost = 198 (general cost) diff --git a/pddl/problem-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl b/pddl/problem-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7599270 --- /dev/null +++ b/pddl/problem-CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1.pddl @@ -0,0 +1,295 @@ +(define (problem CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-1) + + (:domain CIIRC-Testbed-TASE) + + (:objects + P_MaintenanceEngineer-1 - Person + E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 - Equipment + E_Shuttle-3 - Equipment + E_Table-2 - Equipment + E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 - Equipment + E_PositioningUnit-Buffer - Equipment + E_Shuttle-2 - Equipment + E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 - Equipment + E_Robot-1 - Equipment + E_Robot-10 - Equipment + E_Table-10 - Equipment + E_Table-1 - Equipment + E_Shuttle-1 - Equipment + E_Table-3 - Equipment + E_Robot-3 - Equipment + E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 - Equipment + E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 - Equipment + E_Robot-2 - Equipment + ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2 - MaterialLot + ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-2 - MaterialLot + ML_Cabin-Yellow-1 - MaterialLot + ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1 - MaterialLot + ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1 - MaterialLot + ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-1 - MaterialLot + ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10 - MaterialLot + ML_Chassis-Black-1 - MaterialLot + ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 - MaterialLot + ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3 - MaterialLot + ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-3 - MaterialLot + ) + + (:init + (= (total-cost) 0) + (MaterialClassed MD_StakeBed-White-White-White MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_StakeBed-White-White-White MD_Body-StakeBed-White) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_StakeBed-White-White-White MD_Cabin-White) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_StakeBed-White-White-White MD_Chassis-White) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Silver MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Silver MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Silver MC_Cabin) + (MaterialClassed MD_StakeBed-Black-Blue-White MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_StakeBed-Black-Blue-White MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_StakeBed-Black-Blue-White MD_Cabin-Blue) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_StakeBed-Black-Blue-White MD_Body-StakeBed-White) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Dumper-Yellow MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Dumper-Yellow MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Dumper-Yellow MC_Body) + (MaterialClassed MD_Dumper-White-Transparent-Yellow MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Dumper-White-Transparent-Yellow MD_Chassis-White) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Dumper-White-Transparent-Yellow MD_Cabin-Transparent) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Dumper-White-Transparent-Yellow MD_Body-Dumper-Yellow) + (MaterialClassed MD_Tank-Black-White-Black MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Tank-Black-White-Black MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Tank-Black-White-Black MD_Cabin-White) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Tank-Black-White-Black MD_Body-Tank-Black) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue MC_Body) + (MaterialClassed MD_TruckBaseplate MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialClassed MD_TruckBaseplate MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-Black MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-Black MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-Black MC_Chassis) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Yellow MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Yellow MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Yellow MC_Cabin) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Tank-Black MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Tank-Black MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Tank-Black MC_Body) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Blue MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Blue MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Blue MC_Cabin) + (MaterialClassed MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MD_Cabin-Yellow) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue) + (MaterialClassed MD_Dumper-White-Silver-Silver MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Dumper-White-Silver-Silver MD_Chassis-White) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Dumper-White-Silver-Silver MD_Cabin-Silver) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Dumper-White-Silver-Silver MD_Body-Dumper-Silver) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Dumper-Silver MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Dumper-Silver MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Dumper-Silver MC_Body) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-White MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-White MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-White MC_Chassis) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Transparent MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Transparent MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-Transparent MC_Cabin) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-StakeBed-White MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-StakeBed-White MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-StakeBed-White MC_Body) + (MaterialClassed MD_Tank-Black-Blue-Silver MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Tank-Black-Blue-Silver MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Tank-Black-Blue-Silver MD_Cabin-Blue) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_Tank-Black-Blue-Silver MD_Body-Tank-Silver) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-White MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-White MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Cabin-White MC_Cabin) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Tank-Silver MC_Pickable) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Tank-Silver MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialClassed MD_Body-Tank-Silver MC_Body) + (PersonClassed P_MaintenanceEngineer-1 PC_MaintenanceEngineer) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 EC_TransportationNode) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-3 EC_Shuttle) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-3 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-2 EC_Table) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-2 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 EC_TransportationNode) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-Buffer EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-Buffer EC_TransportationNode) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-2 EC_Shuttle) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-2 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 EC_TransportationNode) + (EquipmentClassed E_Robot-1 EC_Robot) + (EquipmentClassed E_Robot-10 EC_Robot) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-10 EC_Table) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-10 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-1 EC_Table) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-1 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-1 EC_Shuttle) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-1 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-3 EC_Table) + (EquipmentClassed E_Table-3 EC_BaseplateCarrier) + (EquipmentClassed E_Robot-3 EC_Robot) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 EC_TransportationNode) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 EC_TransportationNode) + (EquipmentClassed E_Robot-2 EC_Robot) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-2 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-2) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-2 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-2 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialDefined ML_Cabin-Yellow-1 MD_Cabin-Yellow) + (MaterialRaw ML_Cabin-Yellow-1) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Cabin-Yellow-1 MC_Pickable) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Cabin-Yellow-1 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Cabin-Yellow-1 MC_Cabin) + (MaterialDefined ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1 MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue) + (MaterialRaw ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1 MC_Pickable) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1 MC_Body) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-1 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-1) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-1 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-1 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialDefined ML_Chassis-Black-1 MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialRaw ML_Chassis-Black-1) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Chassis-Black-1 MC_Pickable) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Chassis-Black-1 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Chassis-Black-1 MC_Chassis) + (MaterialDefined ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue) + (MaterialRaw ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 MC_Truck) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3 MC_TruckComponent) + (MaterialDefined ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-3 MD_TruckBaseplate) + (MaterialRaw ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-3) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-3 MC_Baseplate) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-3 MC_TruckComponent) + (TransportationNodeOccupied E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (TransportationNodeOccupied E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (TransportationNodeOccupied E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (RobotEnabled E_Robot-1) + (RobotEnabled E_Robot-10) + (RobotEnabled E_Robot-3) + (RobotEnabled E_Robot-2) + (ClassMountable MC_Cabin MC_Chassis) + (ClassMountable MC_Body MC_Chassis) + (ClassMountable MC_Cabin MC_Baseplate) + (ClassMountable MC_Body MC_Baseplate) + (ClassMountable MC_Chassis MC_Baseplate) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-1 E_Table-1) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-2 E_Table-2) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-3 E_Table-3) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-10 E_Table-10) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-10 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1 E_Table-1) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2 E_Table-2) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3 E_Table-3) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10 E_Table-10) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-1 E_Shuttle-1) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-2 E_Shuttle-2) + (MaterialLocation ML_TruckBaseplate-Shuttle-3 E_Shuttle-3) + (Mounted ML_Chassis-Black-1 ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-3) + (Mounted ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1 ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-2) + (Mounted ML_Cabin-Yellow-1 ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-1) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 25) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 30) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 54) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 78) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 37) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 25) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 35) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 59) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 83) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 42) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 28) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 33) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 62) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 86) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 45) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 30) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 35) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 40) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 26) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 47) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 18) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 23) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 28) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 52) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 36) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 51) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 56) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 61) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 22) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 47) + (EquipmentLocation E_Shuttle-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (TransportationNodeOccupied E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (EquipmentLocation E_Shuttle-3 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (TransportationNodeOccupied E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (EquipmentLocation E_Shuttle-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (TransportationNodeOccupied E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + ) + + (:goal + (and + (Mounted ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_TruckBaseplate-Table-10) + (MaterialLotAssembly ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1) + (MaterialLotAssembly ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_Cabin-Yellow-1) + (MaterialLotAssembly ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_Chassis-Black-1) + ) + ) + + (:metric minimize (total-cost)) +) diff --git a/results/out-1-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-1-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4cd73c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.962 218 218.962 218 0.0 +Run 2 0.962 218 218.962 218 0.0 +Run 3 0.974 218 218.974 218 0.0 +Run 4 0.962 218 218.962 218 0.0 +Run 5 0.968 218 218.968 218 0.0 +Run 6 0.962 218 218.962 218 0.0 +Run 7 0.971 218 218.971 218 0.0 +Run 8 0.953 218 218.953 218 0.0 +Run 9 0.956 218 218.956 218 0.0 +Run 10 0.948 218 218.948 218 0.0 +Run 11 0.959 218 218.959 218 0.0 +Run 12 0.97 218 218.97 218 0.0 +Run 13 0.959 218 218.959 218 0.0 +Run 14 0.957 218 218.957 218 0.0 +Run 15 0.958 218 218.958 218 0.0 +Run 16 0.966 218 218.966 218 0.0 +Run 17 0.961 218 218.961 218 0.0 +Run 18 0.939 218 218.939 218 0.0 +Run 19 0.947 218 218.947 218 0.0 +Run 20 0.959 218 218.959 218 0.0 +Run 21 0.949 218 218.949 218 0.0 +Run 22 0.955 218 218.955 218 0.0 +Run 23 0.966 218 218.966 218 0.0 +Run 24 0.958 218 218.958 218 0.0 +Run 25 0.954 218 218.954 218 0.0 +Run 26 0.963 218 218.963 218 0.0 +Run 27 0.957 218 218.957 218 0.0 +Run 28 0.961 218 218.961 218 0.0 +Run 29 1.005 218 219.005 218 0.0 +Run 30 0.946 218 218.946 218 0.0 +Run 31 0.969 218 218.969 218 0.0 +Min 0.939 218 218.939 218 0.0 +First Quartile 0.955 218 218.955 218 0.0 +Median 0.959 218 218.959 218 0.0 +Average 0.961 218 218.961 218 0.0 +Third Quartile 0.966 218 218.966 218 0.0 +Max 1.005 218 219.005 218 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-1-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2dc0903 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.956 172.048 172.992 172.036 0.0 +Run 2 0.957 172.048 172.993 172.036 0.0 +Run 3 0.959 172.048 172.995 172.036 0.0 +Run 4 0.958 172.048 172.994 172.036 0.0 +Run 5 0.956 172.048 172.992 172.036 0.0 +Run 6 0.979 172.048 173.015 172.036 0.0 +Run 7 0.968 172.048 173.004 172.036 0.0 +Run 8 0.957 172.048 172.993 172.036 0.0 +Run 9 0.978 172.048 173.014 172.036 0.0 +Run 10 0.974 172.048 173.010 172.036 0.0 +Run 11 0.968 172.048 173.004 172.036 0.0 +Run 12 0.961 172.048 172.997 172.036 0.0 +Run 13 0.959 172.048 172.995 172.036 0.0 +Run 14 0.962 172.048 172.998 172.036 0.0 +Run 15 0.951 172.048 172.987 172.036 0.0 +Run 16 0.961 172.048 172.997 172.036 0.0 +Run 17 0.978 172.048 173.014 172.036 0.0 +Run 18 0.988 172.048 173.024 172.036 0.0 +Run 19 0.999 172.048 173.035 172.036 0.0 +Run 20 0.963 172.048 172.999 172.036 0.0 +Run 21 0.976 172.048 173.012 172.036 0.0 +Run 22 0.957 172.048 172.993 172.036 0.0 +Run 23 0.981 172.048 173.017 172.036 0.0 +Run 24 0.962 172.048 172.998 172.036 0.0 +Run 25 0.982 172.048 173.018 172.036 0.0 +Run 26 0.962 172.048 172.998 172.036 0.0 +Run 27 0.975 172.048 173.011 172.036 0.0 +Run 28 0.968 172.048 173.004 172.036 0.0 +Run 29 0.945 172.048 172.981 172.036 0.0 +Run 30 0.969 172.048 173.005 172.036 0.0 +Run 31 0.965 172.048 173.001 172.036 0.0 +Min 0.945 172.048 172.981 172.036 0.0 +First Quartile 0.958 172.048 172.994 172.036 0.0 +Median 0.963 172.048 172.999 172.036 0.0 +Average 0.967 172.048 173.003 172.036 0.0 +Third Quartile 0.976 172.048 173.012 172.036 0.0 +Max 0.999 172.048 173.035 172.036 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-1-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..588ad85 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.969 218 218.969 218 0.0 +Run 2 0.922 218 218.922 218 0.0 +Run 3 0.93 218 218.93 218 0.0 +Run 4 0.92 218 218.92 218 0.0 +Run 5 0.926 218 218.926 218 0.0 +Run 6 0.925 218 218.925 218 0.0 +Run 7 0.925 218 218.925 218 0.0 +Run 8 0.924 218 218.924 218 0.0 +Run 9 0.945 218 218.945 218 0.0 +Run 10 0.951 218 218.951 218 0.0 +Run 11 0.931 218 218.931 218 0.0 +Run 12 0.923 218 218.923 218 0.0 +Run 13 0.919 218 218.919 218 0.0 +Run 14 0.937 218 218.937 218 0.0 +Run 15 0.92 218 218.92 218 0.0 +Run 16 0.923 218 218.923 218 0.0 +Run 17 0.94 218 218.94 218 0.0 +Run 18 0.925 218 218.925 218 0.0 +Run 19 0.922 218 218.922 218 0.0 +Run 20 0.923 218 218.923 218 0.0 +Run 21 0.935 218 218.935 218 0.0 +Run 22 0.914 218 218.914 218 0.0 +Run 23 0.948 218 218.948 218 0.0 +Run 24 0.929 218 218.929 218 0.0 +Run 25 0.931 218 218.931 218 0.0 +Run 26 0.917 218 218.917 218 0.0 +Run 27 0.944 218 218.944 218 0.0 +Run 28 0.925 218 218.925 218 0.0 +Run 29 0.921 218 218.921 218 0.0 +Run 30 0.928 218 218.928 218 0.0 +Run 31 0.931 218 218.931 218 0.0 +Min 0.914 218 218.914 218 0.0 +First Quartile 0.922 218 218.922 218 0.0 +Median 0.925 218 218.925 218 0.0 +Average 0.930 218 218.930 218 0.0 +Third Quartile 0.935 218 218.935 218 0.0 +Max 0.969 218 218.969 218 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-1-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fcab89f --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.924 172.048 172.952 172.028 0.0 +Run 2 0.917 172.048 172.945 172.028 0.0 +Run 3 0.917 172.048 172.945 172.028 0.0 +Run 4 1.021 172.048 173.049 172.028 0.0 +Run 5 0.912 172.048 172.940 172.028 0.0 +Run 6 0.946 172.048 172.974 172.028 0.0 +Run 7 0.969 172.048 172.997 172.028 0.0 +Run 8 0.98 172.048 173.008 172.028 0.0 +Run 9 0.952 172.048 172.980 172.028 0.0 +Run 10 0.93 172.048 172.958 172.028 0.0 +Run 11 0.922 172.048 172.950 172.028 0.0 +Run 12 0.919 172.048 172.947 172.028 0.0 +Run 13 0.917 172.048 172.945 172.028 0.0 +Run 14 0.915 172.048 172.943 172.028 0.0 +Run 15 0.925 172.048 172.953 172.028 0.0 +Run 16 0.934 172.048 172.962 172.028 0.0 +Run 17 0.928 172.048 172.956 172.028 0.0 +Run 18 0.919 172.048 172.947 172.028 0.0 +Run 19 0.921 172.048 172.949 172.028 0.0 +Run 20 0.922 172.048 172.950 172.028 0.0 +Run 21 0.927 172.048 172.955 172.028 0.0 +Run 22 0.923 172.048 172.951 172.028 0.0 +Run 23 0.919 172.048 172.947 172.028 0.0 +Run 24 0.947 172.048 172.975 172.028 0.0 +Run 25 0.923 172.048 172.951 172.028 0.0 +Run 26 0.931 172.048 172.959 172.028 0.0 +Run 27 0.93 172.048 172.958 172.028 0.0 +Run 28 0.927 172.048 172.955 172.028 0.0 +Run 29 0.922 172.048 172.950 172.028 0.0 +Run 30 0.931 172.048 172.959 172.028 0.0 +Run 31 0.929 172.048 172.957 172.028 0.0 +Min 0.912 172.048 172.940 172.028 0.0 +First Quartile 0.919 172.048 172.947 172.028 0.0 +Median 0.925 172.048 172.953 172.028 0.0 +Average 0.932 172.048 172.960 172.028 0.0 +Third Quartile 0.931 172.048 172.959 172.028 0.0 +Max 1.021 172.048 173.049 172.028 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-1-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2beed02 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.981 198 198.981 198 0.0 +Run 2 1.008 198 199.008 198 0.0 +Run 3 0.971 198 198.971 198 0.0 +Run 4 0.987 198 198.987 198 0.0 +Run 5 1 198 199 198 0.0 +Run 6 0.984 198 198.984 198 0.0 +Run 7 1.072 198 199.072 198 0.0 +Run 8 1.001 198 199.001 198 0.0 +Run 9 1.043 198 199.043 198 0.0 +Run 10 1.013 198 199.013 198 0.0 +Run 11 1.041 198 199.041 198 0.0 +Run 12 1.039 198 199.039 198 0.0 +Run 13 1.015 198 199.015 198 0.0 +Run 14 1.028 198 199.028 198 0.0 +Run 15 1.055 198 199.055 198 0.0 +Run 16 1.019 198 199.019 198 0.0 +Run 17 0.985 198 198.985 198 0.0 +Run 18 0.993 198 198.993 198 0.0 +Run 19 0.999 198 198.999 198 0.0 +Run 20 1.055 198 199.055 198 0.0 +Run 21 0.994 198 198.994 198 0.0 +Run 22 0.989 198 198.989 198 0.0 +Run 23 0.983 198 198.983 198 0.0 +Run 24 1 198 199 198 0.0 +Run 25 0.997 198 198.997 198 0.0 +Run 26 1.043 198 199.043 198 0.0 +Run 27 1.008 198 199.008 198 0.0 +Run 28 1.045 198 199.045 198 0.0 +Run 29 1.077 198 199.077 198 0.0 +Run 30 1.004 198 199.004 198 0.0 +Run 31 1.005 198 199.005 198 0.0 +Min 0.971 198 198.971 198 0.0 +First Quartile 0.993 198 198.993 198 0.0 +Median 1.005 198 199.005 198 0.0 +Average 1.014 198 199.014 198 0.0 +Third Quartile 1.041 198 199.041 198 0.0 +Max 1.077 198 199.077 198 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-1-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ea21cf8 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.026 129.048 125.068 124.042 4.0 +Run 2 1.002 129.048 125.044 124.042 4.0 +Run 3 1.026 129.048 125.068 124.042 4.0 +Run 4 1.138 129.048 125.180 124.042 4.0 +Run 5 1.001 129.048 125.043 124.042 4.0 +Run 6 1.041 129.048 125.083 124.042 4.0 +Run 7 1 129.048 125.042 124.042 4.0 +Run 8 1.018 129.048 125.060 124.042 4.0 +Run 9 0.989 129.048 125.031 124.042 4.0 +Run 10 1.016 129.048 125.058 124.042 4.0 +Run 11 1.049 129.048 125.091 124.042 4.0 +Run 12 0.975 129.048 125.017 124.042 4.0 +Run 13 0.969 129.048 125.011 124.042 4.0 +Run 14 0.976 129.048 125.018 124.042 4.0 +Run 15 0.989 129.048 125.031 124.042 4.0 +Run 16 0.97 129.048 125.012 124.042 4.0 +Run 17 0.98 129.048 125.022 124.042 4.0 +Run 18 0.993 129.048 125.035 124.042 4.0 +Run 19 0.964 129.048 125.006 124.042 4.0 +Run 20 0.974 129.048 125.016 124.042 4.0 +Run 21 0.975 129.048 125.017 124.042 4.0 +Run 22 0.968 129.048 125.010 124.042 4.0 +Run 23 0.991 129.048 125.033 124.042 4.0 +Run 24 0.971 129.048 125.013 124.042 4.0 +Run 25 0.991 129.048 125.033 124.042 4.0 +Run 26 0.973 129.048 125.015 124.042 4.0 +Run 27 1.006 129.048 125.048 124.042 4.0 +Run 28 0.966 129.048 125.008 124.042 4.0 +Run 29 0.981 129.048 125.023 124.042 4.0 +Run 30 0.982 129.048 125.024 124.042 4.0 +Run 31 0.975 129.048 125.017 124.042 4.0 +Min 0.964 129.048 125.006 124.042 4.0 +First Quartile 0.974 129.048 125.016 124.042 4.0 +Median 0.989 129.048 125.031 124.042 4.0 +Average 0.996 129.048 125.038 124.042 4.0 +Third Quartile 1.006 129.048 125.048 124.042 4.0 +Max 1.138 129.048 125.180 124.042 4.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-1-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..82d4f4f --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.986 198 198.986 198 0.0 +Run 2 0.977 198 198.977 198 0.0 +Run 3 0.985 198 198.985 198 0.0 +Run 4 0.967 198 198.967 198 0.0 +Run 5 0.975 198 198.975 198 0.0 +Run 6 0.969 198 198.969 198 0.0 +Run 7 0.971 198 198.971 198 0.0 +Run 8 0.966 198 198.966 198 0.0 +Run 9 0.973 198 198.973 198 0.0 +Run 10 0.97 198 198.97 198 0.0 +Run 11 0.976 198 198.976 198 0.0 +Run 12 0.983 198 198.983 198 0.0 +Run 13 0.979 198 198.979 198 0.0 +Run 14 0.971 198 198.971 198 0.0 +Run 15 0.972 198 198.972 198 0.0 +Run 16 0.996 198 198.996 198 0.0 +Run 17 0.985 198 198.985 198 0.0 +Run 18 0.975 198 198.975 198 0.0 +Run 19 0.979 198 198.979 198 0.0 +Run 20 0.984 198 198.984 198 0.0 +Run 21 0.978 198 198.978 198 0.0 +Run 22 0.988 198 198.988 198 0.0 +Run 23 0.975 198 198.975 198 0.0 +Run 24 0.97 198 198.97 198 0.0 +Run 25 0.969 198 198.969 198 0.0 +Run 26 0.985 198 198.985 198 0.0 +Run 27 0.973 198 198.973 198 0.0 +Run 28 0.98 198 198.98 198 0.0 +Run 29 0.97 198 198.97 198 0.0 +Run 30 0.964 198 198.964 198 0.0 +Run 31 0.976 198 198.976 198 0.0 +Min 0.964 198 198.964 198 0.0 +First Quartile 0.97 198 198.97 198 0.0 +Median 0.975 198 198.975 198 0.0 +Average 0.976 198 198.976 198 0.0 +Third Quartile 0.983 198 198.983 198 0.0 +Max 0.996 198 198.996 198 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-1-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-1-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f0f400a --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-1-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 0.977 129.048 130.019 129.042 0.0 +Run 2 0.991 129.048 130.033 129.042 0.0 +Run 3 0.975 129.048 130.017 129.042 0.0 +Run 4 0.975 129.048 130.017 129.042 0.0 +Run 5 0.981 129.048 130.023 129.042 0.0 +Run 6 0.976 129.048 130.018 129.042 0.0 +Run 7 0.981 129.048 130.023 129.042 0.0 +Run 8 0.99 129.048 130.032 129.042 0.0 +Run 9 0.968 129.048 130.010 129.042 0.0 +Run 10 0.968 129.048 130.010 129.042 0.0 +Run 11 0.976 129.048 130.018 129.042 0.0 +Run 12 0.984 129.048 130.026 129.042 0.0 +Run 13 0.974 129.048 130.016 129.042 0.0 +Run 14 0.968 129.048 130.010 129.042 0.0 +Run 15 0.977 129.048 130.019 129.042 0.0 +Run 16 0.989 129.048 130.031 129.042 0.0 +Run 17 0.982 129.048 130.024 129.042 0.0 +Run 18 0.973 129.048 130.015 129.042 0.0 +Run 19 0.971 129.048 130.013 129.042 0.0 +Run 20 1.002 129.048 130.044 129.042 0.0 +Run 21 0.974 129.048 130.016 129.042 0.0 +Run 22 0.976 129.048 130.018 129.042 0.0 +Run 23 0.982 129.048 130.024 129.042 0.0 +Run 24 0.974 129.048 130.016 129.042 0.0 +Run 25 0.981 129.048 130.023 129.042 0.0 +Run 26 1.002 129.048 130.044 129.042 0.0 +Run 27 0.975 129.048 130.017 129.042 0.0 +Run 28 0.973 129.048 130.015 129.042 0.0 +Run 29 0.983 129.048 130.025 129.042 0.0 +Run 30 0.973 129.048 130.015 129.042 0.0 +Run 31 0.987 129.048 130.029 129.042 0.0 +Min 0.968 129.048 130.010 129.042 0.0 +First Quartile 0.974 129.048 130.016 129.042 0.0 +Median 0.976 129.048 130.018 129.042 0.0 +Average 0.979 129.048 130.021 129.042 0.0 +Third Quartile 0.983 129.048 130.025 129.042 0.0 +Max 1.002 129.048 130.044 129.042 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-2-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-2-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8f9ed1c --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.526 288 289.526 288 0.0 +Run 2 1.477 288 289.477 288 0.0 +Run 3 1.467 288 289.467 288 0.0 +Run 4 1.474 288 289.474 288 0.0 +Run 5 1.482 288 289.482 288 0.0 +Run 6 1.491 288 289.491 288 0.0 +Run 7 1.486 288 289.486 288 0.0 +Run 8 1.497 288 289.497 288 0.0 +Run 9 1.471 288 289.471 288 0.0 +Run 10 1.459 288 289.459 288 0.0 +Run 11 1.475 288 289.475 288 0.0 +Run 12 1.486 288 289.486 288 0.0 +Run 13 1.47 288 289.47 288 0.0 +Run 14 1.482 288 289.482 288 0.0 +Run 15 1.467 288 289.467 288 0.0 +Run 16 1.502 288 289.502 288 0.0 +Run 17 1.478 288 289.478 288 0.0 +Run 18 1.488 288 289.488 288 0.0 +Run 19 1.475 288 289.475 288 0.0 +Run 20 1.474 288 289.474 288 0.0 +Run 21 1.537 288 289.537 288 0.0 +Run 22 1.482 288 289.482 288 0.0 +Run 23 1.48 288 289.48 288 0.0 +Run 24 1.525 288 289.525 288 0.0 +Run 25 1.473 288 289.473 288 0.0 +Run 26 1.499 288 289.499 288 0.0 +Run 27 1.479 288 289.479 288 0.0 +Run 28 1.453 288 289.453 288 0.0 +Run 29 1.463 288 289.463 288 0.0 +Run 30 1.477 288 289.477 288 0.0 +Run 31 1.503 288 289.503 288 0.0 +Min 1.453 288 289.453 288 0.0 +First Quartile 1.473 288 289.473 288 0.0 +Median 1.479 288 289.479 288 0.0 +Average 1.484 288 289.484 288 0.0 +Third Quartile 1.491 288 289.491 288 0.0 +Max 1.537 288 289.537 288 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-2-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-2-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..392cf24 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.484 222.072 218.546 217.062 2.3 +Run 2 1.468 222.072 218.530 217.062 2.3 +Run 3 1.45 222.072 218.512 217.062 2.3 +Run 4 1.477 222.072 218.539 217.062 2.3 +Run 5 1.567 222.072 218.629 217.062 2.3 +Run 6 1.582 222.072 218.644 217.062 2.3 +Run 7 1.466 222.072 218.528 217.062 2.3 +Run 8 1.482 222.072 218.544 217.062 2.3 +Run 9 1.487 222.072 218.549 217.062 2.3 +Run 10 1.521 222.072 218.583 217.062 2.3 +Run 11 1.472 222.072 218.534 217.062 2.3 +Run 12 1.483 222.072 218.545 217.062 2.3 +Run 13 1.551 222.072 218.613 217.062 2.3 +Run 14 1.511 222.072 218.573 217.062 2.3 +Run 15 1.496 222.072 218.558 217.062 2.3 +Run 16 1.476 222.072 218.538 217.062 2.3 +Run 17 1.491 222.072 218.553 217.062 2.3 +Run 18 1.598 222.072 218.660 217.062 2.3 +Run 19 1.64 222.072 218.702 217.062 2.3 +Run 20 1.629 222.072 218.691 217.062 2.3 +Run 21 1.543 222.072 218.605 217.062 2.3 +Run 22 1.54 222.072 218.602 217.062 2.3 +Run 23 1.51 222.072 218.572 217.062 2.3 +Run 24 1.566 222.072 218.628 217.062 2.3 +Run 25 1.541 222.072 218.603 217.062 2.3 +Run 26 1.592 222.072 218.654 217.062 2.3 +Run 27 1.563 222.072 218.625 217.062 2.3 +Run 28 1.542 222.072 218.604 217.062 2.3 +Run 29 1.523 222.072 218.585 217.062 2.3 +Run 30 1.528 222.072 218.590 217.062 2.3 +Run 31 1.536 222.072 218.598 217.062 2.3 +Min 1.45 222.072 218.512 217.062 2.3 +First Quartile 1.483 222.072 218.545 217.062 2.3 +Median 1.523 222.072 218.585 217.062 2.3 +Average 1.526 222.072 218.588 217.062 2.3 +Third Quartile 1.563 222.072 218.625 217.062 2.3 +Max 1.64 222.072 218.702 217.062 2.3 diff --git a/results/out-2-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-2-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2352e29 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.416 288 289.416 288 0.0 +Run 2 1.46 288 289.46 288 0.0 +Run 3 1.416 288 289.416 288 0.0 +Run 4 1.415 288 289.415 288 0.0 +Run 5 1.413 288 289.413 288 0.0 +Run 6 1.415 288 289.415 288 0.0 +Run 7 1.409 288 289.409 288 0.0 +Run 8 1.409 288 289.409 288 0.0 +Run 9 1.425 288 289.425 288 0.0 +Run 10 1.424 288 289.424 288 0.0 +Run 11 1.406 288 289.406 288 0.0 +Run 12 1.404 288 289.404 288 0.0 +Run 13 1.41 288 289.41 288 0.0 +Run 14 1.41 288 289.41 288 0.0 +Run 15 1.403 288 289.403 288 0.0 +Run 16 1.41 288 289.41 288 0.0 +Run 17 1.414 288 289.414 288 0.0 +Run 18 1.419 288 289.419 288 0.0 +Run 19 1.402 288 289.402 288 0.0 +Run 20 1.414 288 289.414 288 0.0 +Run 21 1.412 288 289.412 288 0.0 +Run 22 1.406 288 289.406 288 0.0 +Run 23 1.411 288 289.411 288 0.0 +Run 24 1.41 288 289.41 288 0.0 +Run 25 1.416 288 289.416 288 0.0 +Run 26 1.453 288 289.453 288 0.0 +Run 27 1.43 288 289.43 288 0.0 +Run 28 1.432 288 289.432 288 0.0 +Run 29 1.418 288 289.418 288 0.0 +Run 30 1.42 288 289.42 288 0.0 +Run 31 1.41 288 289.41 288 0.0 +Min 1.402 288 289.402 288 0.0 +First Quartile 1.41 288 289.41 288 0.0 +Median 1.414 288 289.414 288 0.0 +Average 1.417 288 289.417 288 0.0 +Third Quartile 1.419 288 289.419 288 0.0 +Max 1.46 288 289.46 288 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-2-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-2-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0f307c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.463 222.072 218.529 217.066 2.3 +Run 2 1.406 222.072 218.472 217.066 2.3 +Run 3 1.43 222.072 218.496 217.066 2.3 +Run 4 1.411 222.072 218.477 217.066 2.3 +Run 5 1.403 222.072 218.469 217.066 2.3 +Run 6 1.435 222.072 218.501 217.066 2.3 +Run 7 1.417 222.072 218.483 217.066 2.3 +Run 8 1.415 222.072 218.481 217.066 2.3 +Run 9 1.41 222.072 218.476 217.066 2.3 +Run 10 1.407 222.072 218.473 217.066 2.3 +Run 11 1.409 222.072 218.475 217.066 2.3 +Run 12 1.415 222.072 218.481 217.066 2.3 +Run 13 1.428 222.072 218.494 217.066 2.3 +Run 14 1.472 222.072 218.538 217.066 2.3 +Run 15 1.423 222.072 218.489 217.066 2.3 +Run 16 1.416 222.072 218.482 217.066 2.3 +Run 17 1.433 222.072 218.499 217.066 2.3 +Run 18 1.459 222.072 218.525 217.066 2.3 +Run 19 1.448 222.072 218.514 217.066 2.3 +Run 20 1.575 222.072 218.641 217.066 2.3 +Run 21 1.528 222.072 218.594 217.066 2.3 +Run 22 1.509 222.072 218.575 217.066 2.3 +Run 23 1.51 222.072 218.576 217.066 2.3 +Run 24 1.479 222.072 218.545 217.066 2.3 +Run 25 1.471 222.072 218.537 217.066 2.3 +Run 26 1.605 222.072 218.671 217.066 2.3 +Run 27 1.423 222.072 218.489 217.066 2.3 +Run 28 1.711 222.072 218.777 217.066 2.3 +Run 29 1.429 222.072 218.495 217.066 2.3 +Run 30 1.423 222.072 218.489 217.066 2.3 +Run 31 1.42 222.072 218.486 217.066 2.3 +Min 1.403 222.072 218.469 217.066 2.3 +First Quartile 1.415 222.072 218.481 217.066 2.3 +Median 1.429 222.072 218.495 217.066 2.3 +Average 1.458 222.072 218.524 217.066 2.3 +Third Quartile 1.472 222.072 218.538 217.066 2.3 +Max 1.711 222.072 218.777 217.066 2.3 diff --git a/results/out-2-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-2-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9f674c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.993 283 284.993 283 0.0 +Run 2 2.044 283 285.044 283 0.0 +Run 3 2.044 283 285.044 283 0.0 +Run 4 2.171 283 285.171 283 0.0 +Run 5 2.156 283 285.156 283 0.0 +Run 6 1.996 283 284.996 283 0.0 +Run 7 2.093 283 285.093 283 0.0 +Run 8 2.131 283 285.131 283 0.0 +Run 9 2.096 283 285.096 283 0.0 +Run 10 2.339 283 285.339 283 0.0 +Run 11 1.986 283 284.986 283 0.0 +Run 12 1.985 283 284.985 283 0.0 +Run 13 2.34 283 285.34 283 0.0 +Run 14 2.004 283 285.004 283 0.0 +Run 15 1.997 283 284.997 283 0.0 +Run 16 2.001 283 285.001 283 0.0 +Run 17 2.04 283 285.04 283 0.0 +Run 18 2.06 283 285.06 283 0.0 +Run 19 2.01 283 285.01 283 0.0 +Run 20 2.011 283 285.011 283 0.0 +Run 21 1.998 283 284.998 283 0.0 +Run 22 2.031 283 285.031 283 0.0 +Run 23 2.057 283 285.057 283 0.0 +Run 24 1.985 283 284.985 283 0.0 +Run 25 1.984 283 284.984 283 0.0 +Run 26 2.004 283 285.004 283 0.0 +Run 27 2.307 283 285.307 283 0.0 +Run 28 2.04 283 285.04 283 0.0 +Run 29 2.05 283 285.05 283 0.0 +Run 30 2.1 283 285.1 283 0.0 +Run 31 2.026 283 285.026 283 0.0 +Min 1.984 283 284.984 283 0.0 +First Quartile 1.998 283 284.998 283 0.0 +Median 2.04 283 285.04 283 0.0 +Average 2.067 283 285.067 283 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.096 283 285.096 283 0.0 +Max 2.34 283 285.34 283 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-2-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-2-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..01d5723 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.045 238.076 230.119 228.074 4.4 +Run 2 2.036 238.076 230.110 228.074 4.4 +Run 3 2.043 238.076 230.117 228.074 4.4 +Run 4 2.095 238.076 230.169 228.074 4.4 +Run 5 2.092 238.076 230.166 228.074 4.4 +Run 6 2.045 238.076 230.119 228.074 4.4 +Run 7 2.04 238.076 230.114 228.074 4.4 +Run 8 2.069 238.076 230.143 228.074 4.4 +Run 9 2.024 238.076 230.098 228.074 4.4 +Run 10 2.044 238.076 230.118 228.074 4.4 +Run 11 2.044 238.076 230.118 228.074 4.4 +Run 12 2.021 238.076 230.095 228.074 4.4 +Run 13 2.021 238.076 230.095 228.074 4.4 +Run 14 2.02 238.076 230.094 228.074 4.4 +Run 15 2.016 238.076 230.090 228.074 4.4 +Run 16 2.029 238.076 230.103 228.074 4.4 +Run 17 2.055 238.076 230.129 228.074 4.4 +Run 18 2.023 238.076 230.097 228.074 4.4 +Run 19 1.999 238.076 230.073 228.074 4.4 +Run 20 2.038 238.076 230.112 228.074 4.4 +Run 21 1.997 238.076 230.071 228.074 4.4 +Run 22 1.999 238.076 230.073 228.074 4.4 +Run 23 2.02 238.076 230.094 228.074 4.4 +Run 24 1.997 238.076 230.071 228.074 4.4 +Run 25 2.002 238.076 230.076 228.074 4.4 +Run 26 2.009 238.076 230.083 228.074 4.4 +Run 27 1.993 238.076 230.067 228.074 4.4 +Run 28 2.009 238.076 230.083 228.074 4.4 +Run 29 1.999 238.076 230.073 228.074 4.4 +Run 30 2.021 238.076 230.095 228.074 4.4 +Run 31 2.024 238.076 230.098 228.074 4.4 +Min 1.993 238.076 230.067 228.074 4.4 +First Quartile 2.009 238.076 230.083 228.074 4.4 +Median 2.023 238.076 230.097 228.074 4.4 +Average 2.028 238.076 230.102 228.074 4.4 +Third Quartile 2.044 238.076 230.118 228.074 4.4 +Max 2.095 238.076 230.169 228.074 4.4 diff --git a/results/out-2-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-2-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9f898a2 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.016 283 285.016 283 0.0 +Run 2 2.009 283 285.009 283 0.0 +Run 3 2.006 283 285.006 283 0.0 +Run 4 2.019 283 285.019 283 0.0 +Run 5 2.035 283 285.035 283 0.0 +Run 6 2.002 283 285.002 283 0.0 +Run 7 2.008 283 285.008 283 0.0 +Run 8 2.019 283 285.019 283 0.0 +Run 9 2.029 283 285.029 283 0.0 +Run 10 2.017 283 285.017 283 0.0 +Run 11 2.007 283 285.007 283 0.0 +Run 12 2.023 283 285.023 283 0.0 +Run 13 2.005 283 285.005 283 0.0 +Run 14 2.03 283 285.03 283 0.0 +Run 15 2.002 283 285.002 283 0.0 +Run 16 2.004 283 285.004 283 0.0 +Run 17 2.008 283 285.008 283 0.0 +Run 18 1.992 283 284.992 283 0.0 +Run 19 2.073 283 285.073 283 0.0 +Run 20 2.028 283 285.028 283 0.0 +Run 21 2.036 283 285.036 283 0.0 +Run 22 2.02 283 285.02 283 0.0 +Run 23 2.008 283 285.008 283 0.0 +Run 24 2.008 283 285.008 283 0.0 +Run 25 2.003 283 285.003 283 0.0 +Run 26 1.988 283 284.988 283 0.0 +Run 27 2.026 283 285.026 283 0.0 +Run 28 1.995 283 284.995 283 0.0 +Run 29 1.995 283 284.995 283 0.0 +Run 30 1.995 283 284.995 283 0.0 +Run 31 2.015 283 285.015 283 0.0 +Min 1.988 283 284.988 283 0.0 +First Quartile 2.003 283 285.003 283 0.0 +Median 2.008 283 285.008 283 0.0 +Average 2.014 283 285.014 283 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.023 283 285.023 283 0.0 +Max 2.073 283 285.073 283 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-2-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-2-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2ab8f7f --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-2-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.001 238.076 240.067 238.066 0.0 +Run 2 2.018 238.076 240.084 238.066 0.0 +Run 3 1.977 238.076 240.043 238.066 0.0 +Run 4 2.005 238.076 240.071 238.066 0.0 +Run 5 2.12 238.076 240.186 238.066 0.0 +Run 6 2.035 238.076 240.101 238.066 0.0 +Run 7 2.023 238.076 240.089 238.066 0.0 +Run 8 2.04 238.076 240.106 238.066 0.0 +Run 9 2.057 238.076 240.123 238.066 0.0 +Run 10 2.081 238.076 240.147 238.066 0.0 +Run 11 2.068 238.076 240.134 238.066 0.0 +Run 12 2.063 238.076 240.129 238.066 0.0 +Run 13 2.082 238.076 240.148 238.066 0.0 +Run 14 2.114 238.076 240.180 238.066 0.0 +Run 15 2.137 238.076 240.203 238.066 0.0 +Run 16 2.08 238.076 240.146 238.066 0.0 +Run 17 2.119 238.076 240.185 238.066 0.0 +Run 18 2.313 238.076 240.379 238.066 0.0 +Run 19 2.058 238.076 240.124 238.066 0.0 +Run 20 2.051 238.076 240.117 238.066 0.0 +Run 21 2.428 238.076 240.494 238.066 0.0 +Run 22 2.076 238.076 240.142 238.066 0.0 +Run 23 2.095 238.076 240.161 238.066 0.0 +Run 24 2.021 238.076 240.087 238.066 0.0 +Run 25 2.056 238.076 240.122 238.066 0.0 +Run 26 2.033 238.076 240.099 238.066 0.0 +Run 27 2.077 238.076 240.143 238.066 0.0 +Run 28 1.995 238.076 240.061 238.066 0.0 +Run 29 2.031 238.076 240.097 238.066 0.0 +Run 30 2.008 238.076 240.074 238.066 0.0 +Run 31 2.028 238.076 240.094 238.066 0.0 +Min 1.977 238.076 240.043 238.066 0.0 +First Quartile 2.023 238.076 240.089 238.066 0.0 +Median 2.057 238.076 240.123 238.066 0.0 +Average 2.074 238.076 240.140 238.066 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.082 238.076 240.148 238.066 0.0 +Max 2.428 238.076 240.494 238.066 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-3-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-3-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0ba5272 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.01 428 400.01 398 7.5 +Run 2 2.018 428 410.018 408 4.9 +Run 3 1.996 428 409.996 408 4.9 +Run 4 1.978 428 409.978 408 4.9 +Run 5 1.989 428 429.989 428 0.0 +Run 6 1.963 428 409.963 408 4.9 +Run 7 2.003 428 410.003 408 4.9 +Run 8 2.008 428 420.008 418 2.4 +Run 9 2.001 428 410.001 408 4.9 +Run 10 2.027 428 420.027 418 2.4 +Run 11 1.988 428 409.988 408 4.9 +Run 12 2.012 428 420.012 418 2.4 +Run 13 2.001 428 410.001 408 4.9 +Run 14 1.998 428 419.998 418 2.4 +Run 15 1.984 428 409.984 408 4.9 +Run 16 2.028 428 430.028 428 0.0 +Run 17 1.936 428 429.936 428 0.0 +Run 18 1.993 428 419.993 418 2.4 +Run 19 2.005 428 410.005 408 4.9 +Run 20 2.006 428 400.006 398 7.5 +Run 21 1.991 428 409.991 408 4.9 +Run 22 1.981 428 419.981 418 2.4 +Run 23 2.023 428 420.023 418 2.4 +Run 24 1.994 428 409.994 408 4.9 +Run 25 2.022 428 410.022 408 4.9 +Run 26 2.015 428 400.015 398 7.5 +Run 27 2.01 428 410.01 408 4.9 +Run 28 2.025 428 410.025 408 4.9 +Run 29 2.003 428 410.003 408 4.9 +Run 30 2.013 428 410.013 408 4.9 +Run 31 1.991 428 409.991 408 4.9 +Min 1.936 428 400.006 398 0.0 +First Quartile 1.991 428 409.991 408 2.4 +Median 2.003 428 410.005 408 4.9 +Average 2.000 428 413.226 411 4.1 +Third Quartile 2.013 428 419.998 418 4.9 +Max 2.028 428 430.028 428 7.5 diff --git a/results/out-3-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-3-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b25eeba --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.99 322.126 304.078 302.088 6.6 +Run 2 2.002 322.126 304.090 302.088 6.6 +Run 3 2.012 322.126 304.100 302.088 6.6 +Run 4 2.021 322.126 304.109 302.088 6.6 +Run 5 1.995 322.126 304.083 302.088 6.6 +Run 6 2 322.126 304.088 302.088 6.6 +Run 7 2.005 322.126 304.093 302.088 6.6 +Run 8 2.011 322.126 304.099 302.088 6.6 +Run 9 2.017 322.126 304.105 302.088 6.6 +Run 10 1.987 322.126 304.075 302.088 6.6 +Run 11 1.997 322.126 304.085 302.088 6.6 +Run 12 2.005 322.126 304.093 302.088 6.6 +Run 13 2.018 322.126 304.106 302.088 6.6 +Run 14 1.999 322.126 304.087 302.088 6.6 +Run 15 2.01 322.126 304.098 302.088 6.6 +Run 16 1.995 322.126 304.083 302.088 6.6 +Run 17 2.031 322.126 304.119 302.088 6.6 +Run 18 1.994 322.126 304.082 302.088 6.6 +Run 19 2.011 322.126 304.099 302.088 6.6 +Run 20 1.991 322.126 304.079 302.088 6.6 +Run 21 1.997 322.126 304.085 302.088 6.6 +Run 22 2.001 322.126 304.089 302.088 6.6 +Run 23 2.024 322.126 304.112 302.088 6.6 +Run 24 2.001 322.126 304.089 302.088 6.6 +Run 25 2.007 322.126 304.095 302.088 6.6 +Run 26 1.995 322.126 304.083 302.088 6.6 +Run 27 1.999 322.126 304.087 302.088 6.6 +Run 28 1.962 322.126 304.050 302.088 6.6 +Run 29 2.016 322.126 304.104 302.088 6.6 +Run 30 2.014 322.126 304.102 302.088 6.6 +Run 31 2.037 322.126 304.125 302.088 6.6 +Min 1.962 322.126 304.050 302.088 6.6 +First Quartile 1.995 322.126 304.083 302.088 6.6 +Median 2.002 322.126 304.090 302.088 6.6 +Average 2.005 322.126 304.093 302.088 6.6 +Third Quartile 2.014 322.126 304.102 302.088 6.6 +Max 2.037 322.126 304.125 302.088 6.6 diff --git a/results/out-3-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-3-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3207bc9 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.998 428 419.998 418 2.4 +Run 2 2.04 428 420.04 418 2.4 +Run 3 2.008 428 420.008 418 2.4 +Run 4 1.99 428 419.99 418 2.4 +Run 5 1.986 428 419.986 418 2.4 +Run 6 2.117 428 410.117 408 4.9 +Run 7 1.957 428 419.957 418 2.4 +Run 8 2.139 428 410.139 408 4.9 +Run 9 1.949 428 419.949 418 2.4 +Run 10 2.058 428 420.058 418 2.4 +Run 11 2.026 428 410.026 408 4.9 +Run 12 2.033 428 420.033 418 2.4 +Run 13 1.955 428 419.955 418 2.4 +Run 14 1.973 428 419.973 418 2.4 +Run 15 2.231 428 420.231 418 2.4 +Run 16 2.055 428 420.055 418 2.4 +Run 17 1.951 428 409.951 408 4.9 +Run 18 1.914 428 419.914 418 2.4 +Run 19 1.931 428 419.931 418 2.4 +Run 20 2.189 428 420.189 418 2.4 +Run 21 1.972 428 419.972 418 2.4 +Run 22 1.987 428 419.987 418 2.4 +Run 23 2.141 428 420.141 418 2.4 +Run 24 1.952 428 419.952 418 2.4 +Run 25 2.002 428 410.002 408 4.9 +Run 26 1.932 428 419.932 418 2.4 +Run 27 1.946 428 419.946 418 2.4 +Run 28 2.034 428 420.034 418 2.4 +Run 29 1.951 428 419.951 418 2.4 +Run 30 2.038 428 420.038 418 2.4 +Run 31 2.034 428 420.034 418 2.4 +Min 1.914 428 409.951 408 2.4 +First Quartile 1.952 428 419.932 418 2.4 +Median 1.998 428 419.973 418 2.4 +Average 2.016 428 418.403 416 2.8 +Third Quartile 2.04 428 420.034 418 2.4 +Max 2.231 428 420.231 418 4.9 diff --git a/results/out-3-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-3-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1607d1c --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 1.973 322.126 257.067 255.094 26.3 +Run 2 1.944 322.126 257.038 255.094 26.3 +Run 3 2.015 322.126 257.109 255.094 26.3 +Run 4 2.011 322.126 257.105 255.094 26.3 +Run 5 2.122 322.126 257.216 255.094 26.3 +Run 6 1.954 322.126 257.048 255.094 26.3 +Run 7 1.935 322.126 257.029 255.094 26.3 +Run 8 2.079 322.126 257.173 255.094 26.3 +Run 9 1.967 322.126 257.061 255.094 26.3 +Run 10 1.982 322.126 257.076 255.094 26.3 +Run 11 1.892 322.126 256.986 255.094 26.3 +Run 12 1.876 322.126 256.970 255.094 26.3 +Run 13 1.875 322.126 256.969 255.094 26.3 +Run 14 1.887 322.126 256.981 255.094 26.3 +Run 15 1.874 322.126 256.968 255.094 26.3 +Run 16 1.875 322.126 256.969 255.094 26.3 +Run 17 1.872 322.126 256.966 255.094 26.3 +Run 18 1.86 322.126 256.954 255.094 26.3 +Run 19 1.866 322.126 256.960 255.094 26.3 +Run 20 1.882 322.126 256.976 255.094 26.3 +Run 21 1.869 322.126 256.963 255.094 26.3 +Run 22 1.866 322.126 256.960 255.094 26.3 +Run 23 1.862 322.126 256.956 255.094 26.3 +Run 24 1.879 322.126 256.973 255.094 26.3 +Run 25 1.876 322.126 256.970 255.094 26.3 +Run 26 1.87 322.126 256.964 255.094 26.3 +Run 27 1.883 322.126 256.977 255.094 26.3 +Run 28 1.876 322.126 256.970 255.094 26.3 +Run 29 1.86 322.126 256.954 255.094 26.3 +Run 30 1.866 322.126 256.960 255.094 26.3 +Run 31 1.862 322.126 256.956 255.094 26.3 +Min 1.86 322.126 256.954 255.094 26.3 +First Quartile 1.869 322.126 256.963 255.094 26.3 +Median 1.876 322.126 256.970 255.094 26.3 +Average 1.913 322.126 257.007 255.094 26.3 +Third Quartile 1.954 322.126 257.048 255.094 26.3 +Max 2.122 322.126 257.216 255.094 26.3 diff --git a/results/out-3-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-3-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a8b17eb --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.693 343 345.693 343 0.0 +Run 2 2.708 343 345.708 343 0.0 +Run 3 2.69 343 345.69 343 0.0 +Run 4 2.706 343 345.706 343 0.0 +Run 5 2.677 343 345.677 343 0.0 +Run 6 2.722 343 345.722 343 0.0 +Run 7 2.69 343 345.69 343 0.0 +Run 8 2.704 343 345.704 343 0.0 +Run 9 2.702 343 345.702 343 0.0 +Run 10 2.694 343 345.694 343 0.0 +Run 11 2.679 343 345.679 343 0.0 +Run 12 2.688 343 345.688 343 0.0 +Run 13 2.702 343 345.702 343 0.0 +Run 14 2.703 343 345.703 343 0.0 +Run 15 2.689 343 345.689 343 0.0 +Run 16 2.7 343 345.7 343 0.0 +Run 17 2.688 343 345.688 343 0.0 +Run 18 2.7 343 345.7 343 0.0 +Run 19 2.687 343 345.687 343 0.0 +Run 20 2.692 343 345.692 343 0.0 +Run 21 2.681 343 345.681 343 0.0 +Run 22 2.707 343 345.707 343 0.0 +Run 23 2.71 343 345.71 343 0.0 +Run 24 2.711 343 345.711 343 0.0 +Run 25 2.692 343 345.692 343 0.0 +Run 26 2.678 343 345.678 343 0.0 +Run 27 2.712 343 345.712 343 0.0 +Run 28 2.679 343 345.679 343 0.0 +Run 29 2.689 343 345.689 343 0.0 +Run 30 2.688 343 345.688 343 0.0 +Run 31 2.679 343 345.679 343 0.0 +Min 2.677 343 345.677 343 0.0 +First Quartile 2.688 343 345.688 343 0.0 +Median 2.692 343 345.692 343 0.0 +Average 2.695 343 345.695 343 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.704 343 345.704 343 0.0 +Max 2.722 343 345.722 343 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-3-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-3-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bc09726 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.707 293.100 295.791 293.084 0.0 +Run 2 2.701 293.100 295.785 293.084 0.0 +Run 3 2.689 293.100 295.773 293.084 0.0 +Run 4 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Run 5 2.687 293.100 295.771 293.084 0.0 +Run 6 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Run 7 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Run 8 2.704 293.100 295.788 293.084 0.0 +Run 9 2.701 293.100 295.785 293.084 0.0 +Run 10 2.687 293.100 295.771 293.084 0.0 +Run 11 2.692 293.100 295.776 293.084 0.0 +Run 12 2.726 293.100 295.810 293.084 0.0 +Run 13 2.697 293.100 295.781 293.084 0.0 +Run 14 2.67 293.100 295.754 293.084 0.0 +Run 15 2.663 293.100 295.747 293.084 0.0 +Run 16 2.685 293.100 295.769 293.084 0.0 +Run 17 2.69 293.100 295.774 293.084 0.0 +Run 18 2.684 293.100 295.768 293.084 0.0 +Run 19 2.695 293.100 295.779 293.084 0.0 +Run 20 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Run 21 2.681 293.100 295.765 293.084 0.0 +Run 22 2.711 293.100 295.795 293.084 0.0 +Run 23 2.703 293.100 295.787 293.084 0.0 +Run 24 2.674 293.100 295.758 293.084 0.0 +Run 25 2.692 293.100 295.776 293.084 0.0 +Run 26 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Run 27 2.704 293.100 295.788 293.084 0.0 +Run 28 2.7 293.100 295.784 293.084 0.0 +Run 29 2.69 293.100 295.774 293.084 0.0 +Run 30 2.69 293.100 295.774 293.084 0.0 +Run 31 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Min 2.663 293.100 295.747 293.084 0.0 +First Quartile 2.68 293.100 295.764 293.084 0.0 +Median 2.69 293.100 295.774 293.084 0.0 +Average 2.690 293.100 295.774 293.084 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.701 293.100 295.785 293.084 0.0 +Max 2.726 293.100 295.810 293.084 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-3-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-3-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..074932d --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.691 343 345.691 343 0.0 +Run 2 2.696 343 345.696 343 0.0 +Run 3 2.751 343 345.751 343 0.0 +Run 4 2.699 343 345.699 343 0.0 +Run 5 2.703 343 345.703 343 0.0 +Run 6 2.673 343 345.673 343 0.0 +Run 7 2.672 343 345.672 343 0.0 +Run 8 2.713 343 345.713 343 0.0 +Run 9 2.709 343 345.709 343 0.0 +Run 10 2.689 343 345.689 343 0.0 +Run 11 2.678 343 345.678 343 0.0 +Run 12 2.686 343 345.686 343 0.0 +Run 13 2.679 343 345.679 343 0.0 +Run 14 2.694 343 345.694 343 0.0 +Run 15 2.703 343 345.703 343 0.0 +Run 16 2.703 343 345.703 343 0.0 +Run 17 2.681 343 345.681 343 0.0 +Run 18 2.713 343 345.713 343 0.0 +Run 19 2.688 343 345.688 343 0.0 +Run 20 2.694 343 345.694 343 0.0 +Run 21 2.68 343 345.68 343 0.0 +Run 22 2.675 343 345.675 343 0.0 +Run 23 2.685 343 345.685 343 0.0 +Run 24 2.705 343 345.705 343 0.0 +Run 25 2.713 343 345.713 343 0.0 +Run 26 2.815 343 345.815 343 0.0 +Run 27 2.861 343 345.861 343 0.0 +Run 28 2.825 343 345.825 343 0.0 +Run 29 3 343 346 343 0.0 +Run 30 3 343 346 343 0.0 +Run 31 2.91 343 345.91 343 0.0 +Min 2.672 343 345.672 343 0.0 +First Quartile 2.685 343 345.685 343 0.0 +Median 2.699 343 345.699 343 0.0 +Average 2.735 343 345.735 343 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.713 343 345.713 343 0.0 +Max 3 343 346 343 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-3-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-3-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c4199a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-3-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 2.754 293.100 295.838 293.084 0.0 +Run 2 2.758 293.100 295.842 293.084 0.0 +Run 3 2.783 293.100 295.867 293.084 0.0 +Run 4 2.739 293.100 295.823 293.084 0.0 +Run 5 2.742 293.100 295.826 293.084 0.0 +Run 6 2.79 293.100 295.874 293.084 0.0 +Run 7 2.784 293.100 295.868 293.084 0.0 +Run 8 2.757 293.100 295.841 293.084 0.0 +Run 9 2.746 293.100 295.830 293.084 0.0 +Run 10 2.755 293.100 295.839 293.084 0.0 +Run 11 2.776 293.100 295.860 293.084 0.0 +Run 12 2.754 293.100 295.838 293.084 0.0 +Run 13 2.713 293.100 295.797 293.084 0.0 +Run 14 2.778 293.100 295.862 293.084 0.0 +Run 15 2.756 293.100 295.840 293.084 0.0 +Run 16 2.761 293.100 295.845 293.084 0.0 +Run 17 2.753 293.100 295.837 293.084 0.0 +Run 18 2.729 293.100 295.813 293.084 0.0 +Run 19 2.733 293.100 295.817 293.084 0.0 +Run 20 2.874 293.100 295.958 293.084 0.0 +Run 21 2.736 293.100 295.820 293.084 0.0 +Run 22 2.901 293.100 295.985 293.084 0.0 +Run 23 2.823 293.100 295.907 293.084 0.0 +Run 24 2.87 293.100 295.954 293.084 0.0 +Run 25 3.207 293.100 296.291 293.084 0.0 +Run 26 3.496 293.100 296.580 293.084 0.0 +Run 27 2.745 293.100 295.829 293.084 0.0 +Run 28 2.777 293.100 295.861 293.084 0.0 +Run 29 2.723 293.100 295.807 293.084 0.0 +Run 30 2.718 293.100 295.802 293.084 0.0 +Run 31 2.715 293.100 295.799 293.084 0.0 +Min 2.713 293.100 295.797 293.084 0.0 +First Quartile 2.739 293.100 295.823 293.084 0.0 +Median 2.756 293.100 295.840 293.084 0.0 +Average 2.805 293.100 295.889 293.084 0.0 +Third Quartile 2.784 293.100 295.868 293.084 0.0 +Max 3.496 293.100 296.580 293.084 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-4-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-4-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..12d1a6e --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 3.389 578 501.389 498 16.1 +Run 2 3.869 578 501.869 498 16.1 +Run 3 3.238 578 501.238 498 16.1 +Run 4 3.256 578 471.256 468 23.5 +Run 5 3.26 578 501.26 498 16.1 +Run 6 3.253 578 501.253 498 16.1 +Run 7 3.245 578 501.245 498 16.1 +Run 8 3.271 578 471.271 468 23.5 +Run 9 3.243 578 501.243 498 16.1 +Run 10 3.263 578 471.263 468 23.5 +Run 11 3.266 578 501.266 498 16.1 +Run 12 3.248 578 501.248 498 16.1 +Run 13 3.25 578 471.25 468 23.5 +Run 14 3.294 578 501.294 498 16.1 +Run 15 3.265 578 501.265 498 16.1 +Run 16 3.264 578 501.264 498 16.1 +Run 17 3.283 578 501.283 498 16.1 +Run 18 3.232 578 501.232 498 16.1 +Run 19 3.247 578 501.247 498 16.1 +Run 20 3.254 578 501.254 498 16.1 +Run 21 3.235 578 581.235 578 0.0 +Run 22 3.26 578 471.26 468 23.5 +Run 23 3.244 578 501.244 498 16.1 +Run 24 3.246 578 501.246 498 16.1 +Run 25 3.278 578 501.278 498 16.1 +Run 26 3.263 578 501.263 498 16.1 +Run 27 3.253 578 471.253 468 23.5 +Run 28 3.254 578 501.254 498 16.1 +Run 29 3.231 578 501.231 498 16.1 +Run 30 3.263 578 471.263 468 23.5 +Run 31 3.254 578 501.254 498 16.1 +Min 3.231 578 471.25 468 0.0 +First Quartile 3.246 578 501.231 498 16.1 +Median 3.254 578 501.248 498 16.1 +Average 3.280 578 497.086 494 17.3 +Third Quartile 3.265 578 501.265 498 16.1 +Max 3.869 578 581.235 578 23.5 diff --git a/results/out-4-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-4-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d90df30 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 3.235 412.174 400.371 397.136 3.8 +Run 2 3.27 412.174 400.406 397.136 3.8 +Run 3 3.254 412.174 400.390 397.136 3.8 +Run 4 3.321 412.174 400.457 397.136 3.8 +Run 5 3.258 412.174 400.394 397.136 3.8 +Run 6 3.359 412.174 400.495 397.136 3.8 +Run 7 3.231 412.174 400.367 397.136 3.8 +Run 8 3.214 412.174 400.350 397.136 3.8 +Run 9 3.33 412.174 400.466 397.136 3.8 +Run 10 3.258 412.174 400.394 397.136 3.8 +Run 11 3.241 412.174 400.377 397.136 3.8 +Run 12 3.227 412.174 400.363 397.136 3.8 +Run 13 3.216 412.174 400.352 397.136 3.8 +Run 14 3.236 412.174 400.372 397.136 3.8 +Run 15 3.272 412.174 400.408 397.136 3.8 +Run 16 3.299 412.174 400.435 397.136 3.8 +Run 17 3.249 412.174 400.385 397.136 3.8 +Run 18 3.211 412.174 400.347 397.136 3.8 +Run 19 3.237 412.174 400.373 397.136 3.8 +Run 20 3.215 412.174 400.351 397.136 3.8 +Run 21 3.252 412.174 400.388 397.136 3.8 +Run 22 3.251 412.174 400.387 397.136 3.8 +Run 23 3.253 412.174 400.389 397.136 3.8 +Run 24 3.248 412.174 400.384 397.136 3.8 +Run 25 3.239 412.174 400.375 397.136 3.8 +Run 26 3.24 412.174 400.376 397.136 3.8 +Run 27 3.249 412.174 400.385 397.136 3.8 +Run 28 3.293 412.174 400.429 397.136 3.8 +Run 29 3.232 412.174 400.368 397.136 3.8 +Run 30 3.245 412.174 400.381 397.136 3.8 +Run 31 3.242 412.174 400.378 397.136 3.8 +Min 3.211 412.174 400.347 397.136 3.8 +First Quartile 3.235 412.174 400.371 397.136 3.8 +Median 3.248 412.174 400.384 397.136 3.8 +Average 3.254 412.174 400.390 397.136 3.8 +Third Quartile 3.258 412.174 400.394 397.136 3.8 +Max 3.359 412.174 400.495 397.136 3.8 diff --git a/results/out-4-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-4-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1073dd9 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 3.738 578 517.738 514 12.5 +Run 2 3.373 578 517.373 514 12.5 +Run 3 3.857 578 517.857 514 12.5 +Run 4 3.309 578 517.309 514 12.5 +Run 5 3.4 578 517.4 514 12.5 +Run 6 3.316 578 517.316 514 12.5 +Run 7 3.319 578 517.319 514 12.5 +Run 8 3.317 578 517.317 514 12.5 +Run 9 3.415 578 517.415 514 12.5 +Run 10 3.295 578 517.295 514 12.5 +Run 11 3.35 578 517.35 514 12.5 +Run 12 3.388 578 517.388 514 12.5 +Run 13 3.325 578 517.325 514 12.5 +Run 14 3.313 578 517.313 514 12.5 +Run 15 3.294 578 517.294 514 12.5 +Run 16 3.317 578 517.317 514 12.5 +Run 17 3.305 578 517.305 514 12.5 +Run 18 3.314 578 517.314 514 12.5 +Run 19 3.294 578 517.294 514 12.5 +Run 20 3.368 578 517.368 514 12.5 +Run 21 3.3 578 517.3 514 12.5 +Run 22 3.318 578 517.318 514 12.5 +Run 23 3.345 578 517.345 514 12.5 +Run 24 3.322 578 517.322 514 12.5 +Run 25 3.303 578 517.303 514 12.5 +Run 26 3.355 578 517.355 514 12.5 +Run 27 3.381 578 517.381 514 12.5 +Run 28 3.332 578 517.332 514 12.5 +Run 29 3.312 578 517.312 514 12.5 +Run 30 3.31 578 517.31 514 12.5 +Run 31 3.41 578 517.41 514 12.5 +Min 3.294 578 517.294 514 12.5 +First Quartile 3.31 578 517.31 514 12.5 +Median 3.319 578 517.319 514 12.5 +Average 3.364 578 517.364 514 12.5 +Third Quartile 3.373 578 517.373 514 12.5 +Max 3.857 578 517.857 514 12.5 diff --git a/results/out-4-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-4-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..80e29f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 3.278 412.174 409.410 406.132 1.5 +Run 2 3.307 412.174 409.439 406.132 1.5 +Run 3 3.245 412.174 409.377 406.132 1.5 +Run 4 3.254 412.174 409.386 406.132 1.5 +Run 5 3.257 412.174 409.389 406.132 1.5 +Run 6 3.24 412.174 409.372 406.132 1.5 +Run 7 3.267 412.174 409.399 406.132 1.5 +Run 8 3.238 412.174 409.370 406.132 1.5 +Run 9 3.254 412.174 409.386 406.132 1.5 +Run 10 3.263 412.174 409.395 406.132 1.5 +Run 11 3.254 412.174 409.386 406.132 1.5 +Run 12 3.254 412.174 409.386 406.132 1.5 +Run 13 3.301 412.174 409.433 406.132 1.5 +Run 14 3.272 412.174 409.404 406.132 1.5 +Run 15 3.271 412.174 409.403 406.132 1.5 +Run 16 3.249 412.174 409.381 406.132 1.5 +Run 17 3.247 412.174 409.379 406.132 1.5 +Run 18 3.227 412.174 409.359 406.132 1.5 +Run 19 3.265 412.174 409.397 406.132 1.5 +Run 20 3.262 412.174 409.394 406.132 1.5 +Run 21 3.271 412.174 409.403 406.132 1.5 +Run 22 3.245 412.174 409.377 406.132 1.5 +Run 23 3.252 412.174 409.384 406.132 1.5 +Run 24 3.305 412.174 409.437 406.132 1.5 +Run 25 3.248 412.174 409.380 406.132 1.5 +Run 26 3.323 412.174 409.455 406.132 1.5 +Run 27 3.273 412.174 409.405 406.132 1.5 +Run 28 3.259 412.174 409.391 406.132 1.5 +Run 29 3.253 412.174 409.385 406.132 1.5 +Run 30 3.245 412.174 409.377 406.132 1.5 +Run 31 3.241 412.174 409.373 406.132 1.5 +Min 3.227 412.174 409.359 406.132 1.5 +First Quartile 3.247 412.174 409.379 406.132 1.5 +Median 3.254 412.174 409.386 406.132 1.5 +Average 3.262 412.174 409.394 406.132 1.5 +Third Quartile 3.271 412.174 409.403 406.132 1.5 +Max 3.323 412.174 409.455 406.132 1.5 diff --git a/results/out-4-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-4-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d9b5f20 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.447 517 522.447 517 0.0 +Run 2 5.442 517 522.442 517 0.0 +Run 3 5.499 517 522.499 517 0.0 +Run 4 5.396 517 522.396 517 0.0 +Run 5 5.403 517 522.403 517 0.0 +Run 6 5.426 517 522.426 517 0.0 +Run 7 5.416 517 522.416 517 0.0 +Run 8 5.467 517 522.467 517 0.0 +Run 9 5.44 517 522.44 517 0.0 +Run 10 5.483 517 522.483 517 0.0 +Run 11 5.416 517 522.416 517 0.0 +Run 12 5.416 517 522.416 517 0.0 +Run 13 5.416 517 522.416 517 0.0 +Run 14 5.424 517 522.424 517 0.0 +Run 15 5.419 517 522.419 517 0.0 +Run 16 5.45 517 522.45 517 0.0 +Run 17 5.476 517 522.476 517 0.0 +Run 18 5.443 517 522.443 517 0.0 +Run 19 5.441 517 522.441 517 0.0 +Run 20 5.498 517 522.498 517 0.0 +Run 21 5.413 517 522.413 517 0.0 +Run 22 5.791 517 522.791 517 0.0 +Run 23 6.106 517 523.106 517 0.0 +Run 24 6.112 517 523.112 517 0.0 +Run 25 6.183 517 523.183 517 0.0 +Run 26 6.445 517 523.445 517 0.0 +Run 27 6.098 517 523.098 517 0.0 +Run 28 6.119 517 523.119 517 0.0 +Run 29 5.853 517 522.853 517 0.0 +Run 30 5.985 517 522.985 517 0.0 +Run 31 5.83 517 522.83 517 0.0 +Min 5.396 517 522.396 517 0.0 +First Quartile 5.419 517 522.419 517 0.0 +Median 5.45 517 522.45 517 0.0 +Average 5.637 517 522.637 517 0.0 +Third Quartile 5.853 517 522.853 517 0.0 +Max 6.445 517 523.445 517 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-4-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-4-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f03da3f --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.833 452.150 340.979 335.146 34.9 +Run 2 5.913 452.150 341.059 335.146 34.9 +Run 3 6.072 452.150 341.218 335.146 34.9 +Run 4 5.966 452.150 341.112 335.146 34.9 +Run 5 6.001 452.150 341.147 335.146 34.9 +Run 6 5.9 452.150 341.046 335.146 34.9 +Run 7 5.773 452.150 340.919 335.146 34.9 +Run 8 6.377 452.150 341.523 335.146 34.9 +Run 9 5.839 452.150 340.985 335.146 34.9 +Run 10 6.279 452.150 341.425 335.146 34.9 +Run 11 5.755 452.150 340.901 335.146 34.9 +Run 12 5.95 452.150 341.096 335.146 34.9 +Run 13 6.195 452.150 341.341 335.146 34.9 +Run 14 6.134 452.150 341.280 335.146 34.9 +Run 15 6.13 452.150 341.276 335.146 34.9 +Run 16 6.718 452.150 341.864 335.146 34.9 +Run 17 5.725 452.150 340.871 335.146 34.9 +Run 18 5.71 452.150 340.856 335.146 34.9 +Run 19 5.63 452.150 340.776 335.146 34.9 +Run 20 5.703 452.150 340.849 335.146 34.9 +Run 21 5.643 452.150 340.789 335.146 34.9 +Run 22 5.676 452.150 340.822 335.146 34.9 +Run 23 5.769 452.150 340.915 335.146 34.9 +Run 24 5.847 452.150 340.993 335.146 34.9 +Run 25 5.744 452.150 340.890 335.146 34.9 +Run 26 5.882 452.150 341.028 335.146 34.9 +Run 27 5.712 452.150 340.858 335.146 34.9 +Run 28 5.927 452.150 341.073 335.146 34.9 +Run 29 5.838 452.150 340.984 335.146 34.9 +Run 30 5.899 452.150 341.045 335.146 34.9 +Run 31 5.733 452.150 340.879 335.146 34.9 +Min 5.63 452.150 340.776 335.146 34.9 +First Quartile 5.733 452.150 340.879 335.146 34.9 +Median 5.847 452.150 340.993 335.146 34.9 +Average 5.912 452.150 341.058 335.146 34.9 +Third Quartile 6.001 452.150 341.147 335.146 34.9 +Max 6.718 452.150 341.864 335.146 34.9 diff --git a/results/out-4-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-4-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6d86f7d --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.689 517 490.689 485 6.6 +Run 2 5.915 517 490.915 485 6.6 +Run 3 5.852 517 490.852 485 6.6 +Run 4 5.705 517 480.705 475 8.8 +Run 5 6.486 517 491.486 485 6.6 +Run 6 5.824 517 480.824 475 8.8 +Run 7 5.964 517 480.964 475 8.8 +Run 8 5.734 517 480.734 475 8.8 +Run 9 5.631 517 490.631 485 6.6 +Run 10 5.675 517 480.675 475 8.8 +Run 11 6.081 517 481.081 475 8.8 +Run 12 5.741 517 490.741 485 6.6 +Run 13 5.927 517 480.927 475 8.8 +Run 14 5.812 517 480.812 475 8.8 +Run 15 5.742 517 480.742 475 8.8 +Run 16 5.85 517 490.85 485 6.6 +Run 17 5.652 517 480.652 475 8.8 +Run 18 5.907 517 480.907 475 8.8 +Run 19 5.717 517 480.717 475 8.8 +Run 20 5.732 517 480.732 475 8.8 +Run 21 5.804 517 480.804 475 8.8 +Run 22 5.663 517 480.663 475 8.8 +Run 23 5.844 517 480.844 475 8.8 +Run 24 5.801 517 480.801 475 8.8 +Run 25 5.717 517 480.717 475 8.8 +Run 26 5.8 517 490.8 485 6.6 +Run 27 5.819 517 490.819 485 6.6 +Run 28 5.794 517 490.794 485 6.6 +Run 29 5.821 517 480.821 475 8.8 +Run 30 5.785 517 480.785 475 8.8 +Run 31 5.792 517 490.792 485 6.6 +Min 5.631 517 480.652 475 6.6 +First Quartile 5.717 517 480.734 475 6.6 +Median 5.8 517 480.844 475 8.8 +Average 5.815 517 484.364 479 8.0 +Third Quartile 5.85 517 490.792 485 8.8 +Max 6.486 517 491.486 485 8.8 diff --git a/results/out-4-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-4-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e0c485f --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-4-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.951 452.150 431.067 425.116 6.4 +Run 2 6.655 452.150 431.773 425.118 6.4 +Run 3 5.885 452.150 431.001 425.116 6.4 +Run 4 6.029 452.150 431.145 425.116 6.4 +Run 5 5.814 452.150 430.930 425.116 6.4 +Run 6 5.919 452.150 431.035 425.116 6.4 +Run 7 5.828 452.150 430.944 425.116 6.4 +Run 8 5.803 452.150 430.919 425.116 6.4 +Run 9 5.816 452.150 430.932 425.116 6.4 +Run 10 5.679 452.150 430.795 425.116 6.4 +Run 11 5.993 452.150 431.109 425.116 6.4 +Run 12 5.998 452.150 431.114 425.116 6.4 +Run 13 6.269 452.150 431.387 425.118 6.4 +Run 14 5.81 452.150 430.926 425.116 6.4 +Run 15 5.914 452.150 431.030 425.116 6.4 +Run 16 5.79 452.150 430.908 425.118 6.4 +Run 17 5.786 452.150 430.902 425.116 6.4 +Run 18 5.726 452.150 430.842 425.116 6.4 +Run 19 5.808 452.150 430.924 425.116 6.4 +Run 20 6.009 452.150 431.125 425.116 6.4 +Run 21 6.163 452.150 431.279 425.116 6.4 +Run 22 5.796 452.150 430.912 425.116 6.4 +Run 23 5.735 452.150 430.853 425.118 6.4 +Run 24 6.58 452.150 431.696 425.116 6.4 +Run 25 5.732 452.150 430.848 425.116 6.4 +Run 26 6.055 452.150 431.171 425.116 6.4 +Run 27 5.931 452.150 431.049 425.118 6.4 +Run 28 6.108 452.150 431.226 425.118 6.4 +Run 29 5.749 452.150 430.865 425.116 6.4 +Run 30 5.888 452.150 431.004 425.116 6.4 +Run 31 5.91 452.150 431.026 425.116 6.4 +Min 5.679 452.150 430.795 425.116 6.4 +First Quartile 5.796 452.150 430.912 425.116 6.4 +Median 5.888 452.150 431.004 425.116 6.4 +Average 5.940 452.150 431.056 425.116 6.4 +Third Quartile 6.009 452.150 431.125 425.116 6.4 +Max 6.655 452.150 431.773 425.118 6.4 diff --git a/results/out-5-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-5-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0035906 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.98 658 613.98 608 8.2 +Run 2 6.01 658 594.01 588 11.9 +Run 3 6.042 658 594.042 588 11.9 +Run 4 5.998 658 613.998 608 8.2 +Run 5 5.974 658 613.974 608 8.2 +Run 6 5.971 658 613.971 608 8.2 +Run 7 6.06 658 594.06 588 11.9 +Run 8 5.949 658 613.949 608 8.2 +Run 9 6.036 658 614.036 608 8.2 +Run 10 6.068 658 614.068 608 8.2 +Run 11 6.029 658 664.029 658 0.0 +Run 12 6.04 658 594.04 588 11.9 +Run 13 5.965 658 613.965 608 8.2 +Run 14 5.931 658 613.931 608 8.2 +Run 15 5.944 658 613.944 608 8.2 +Run 16 5.952 658 593.952 588 11.9 +Run 17 5.958 658 613.958 608 8.2 +Run 18 5.954 658 613.954 608 8.2 +Run 19 6.011 658 614.011 608 8.2 +Run 20 6.064 658 594.064 588 11.9 +Run 21 5.932 658 613.932 608 8.2 +Run 22 5.952 658 613.952 608 8.2 +Run 23 6.073 658 614.073 608 8.2 +Run 24 6.017 658 614.017 608 8.2 +Run 25 5.976 658 593.976 588 11.9 +Run 26 6.035 658 594.035 588 11.9 +Run 27 6.118 658 594.118 588 11.9 +Run 28 5.97 658 593.97 588 11.9 +Run 29 6.071 658 664.071 658 0.0 +Run 30 6.127 658 594.127 588 11.9 +Run 31 5.977 658 613.977 608 8.2 +Min 5.931 658 593.952 588 0.0 +First Quartile 5.958 658 594.06 588 8.2 +Median 5.998 658 613.952 608 8.2 +Average 6.006 658 610.135 604 9.0 +Third Quartile 6.042 658 613.998 608 11.9 +Max 6.127 658 664.071 658 11.9 diff --git a/results/out-5-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-5-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a6c4360 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.847 482.214 448.021 442.174 9.1 +Run 2 5.841 482.214 448.015 442.174 9.1 +Run 3 5.806 482.214 447.980 442.174 9.1 +Run 4 5.842 482.214 448.016 442.174 9.1 +Run 5 5.809 482.214 447.983 442.174 9.1 +Run 6 5.858 482.214 448.032 442.174 9.1 +Run 7 5.846 482.214 448.020 442.174 9.1 +Run 8 5.842 482.214 448.016 442.174 9.1 +Run 9 5.83 482.214 448.004 442.174 9.1 +Run 10 5.821 482.214 447.995 442.174 9.1 +Run 11 5.822 482.214 447.996 442.174 9.1 +Run 12 5.823 482.214 447.997 442.174 9.1 +Run 13 5.82 482.214 447.994 442.174 9.1 +Run 14 5.814 482.214 447.988 442.174 9.1 +Run 15 5.812 482.214 447.986 442.174 9.1 +Run 16 5.858 482.214 448.032 442.174 9.1 +Run 17 5.811 482.214 447.985 442.174 9.1 +Run 18 5.83 482.214 448.004 442.174 9.1 +Run 19 5.88 482.214 448.054 442.174 9.1 +Run 20 5.863 482.214 448.037 442.174 9.1 +Run 21 5.848 482.214 448.022 442.174 9.1 +Run 22 5.819 482.214 447.993 442.174 9.1 +Run 23 5.843 482.214 448.017 442.174 9.1 +Run 24 5.887 482.214 448.061 442.174 9.1 +Run 25 5.822 482.214 447.996 442.174 9.1 +Run 26 5.844 482.214 448.018 442.174 9.1 +Run 27 5.857 482.214 448.031 442.174 9.1 +Run 28 5.833 482.214 448.007 442.174 9.1 +Run 29 5.832 482.214 448.006 442.174 9.1 +Run 30 5.847 482.214 448.021 442.174 9.1 +Run 31 5.862 482.214 448.036 442.174 9.1 +Min 5.806 482.214 447.980 442.174 9.1 +First Quartile 5.821 482.214 447.995 442.174 9.1 +Median 5.841 482.214 448.015 442.174 9.1 +Average 5.838 482.214 448.012 442.174 9.1 +Third Quartile 5.848 482.214 448.022 442.174 9.1 +Max 5.887 482.214 448.061 442.174 9.1 diff --git a/results/out-5-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-5-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..742eb94 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 5.959 658 633.959 628 4.8 +Run 2 6.469 658 634.469 628 4.8 +Run 3 6.501 658 634.501 628 4.8 +Run 4 6.27 658 624.27 618 6.5 +Run 5 6.251 658 634.251 628 4.8 +Run 6 6.416 658 624.416 618 6.5 +Run 7 6.237 658 634.237 628 4.8 +Run 8 6.306 658 624.306 618 6.5 +Run 9 6.257 658 634.257 628 4.8 +Run 10 7.053 658 635.053 628 4.8 +Run 11 6.471 658 634.471 628 4.8 +Run 12 6.613 658 624.613 618 6.5 +Run 13 6.241 658 624.241 618 6.5 +Run 14 6.446 658 634.446 628 4.8 +Run 15 6.666 658 634.666 628 4.8 +Run 16 6.369 658 634.369 628 4.8 +Run 17 6.379 658 624.379 618 6.5 +Run 18 6.421 658 624.421 618 6.5 +Run 19 6.386 658 634.386 628 4.8 +Run 20 6.335 658 624.335 618 6.5 +Run 21 6.375 658 624.375 618 6.5 +Run 22 6.373 658 634.373 628 4.8 +Run 23 6.374 658 634.374 628 4.8 +Run 24 6.283 658 624.283 618 6.5 +Run 25 6.76 658 634.76 628 4.8 +Run 26 6.865 658 624.865 618 6.5 +Run 27 6.672 658 624.672 618 6.5 +Run 28 6.455 658 634.455 628 4.8 +Run 29 6.072 658 624.072 618 6.5 +Run 30 6.47 658 634.47 628 4.8 +Run 31 6.298 658 634.298 628 4.8 +Min 5.959 658 624.072 618 4.8 +First Quartile 6.283 658 624.379 618 4.8 +Median 6.379 658 634.251 628 4.8 +Average 6.421 658 630.227 624 5.5 +Third Quartile 6.471 658 634.455 628 6.5 +Max 7.053 658 635.053 628 6.5 diff --git a/results/out-5-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-5-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b30a0d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 6.518 482.214 448.686 442.168 9.1 +Run 2 6.359 482.214 448.527 442.168 9.1 +Run 3 6.372 482.214 448.540 442.168 9.1 +Run 4 6.327 482.214 448.495 442.168 9.1 +Run 5 6.395 482.214 448.563 442.168 9.1 +Run 6 6.288 482.214 448.456 442.168 9.1 +Run 7 6.522 482.214 448.690 442.168 9.1 +Run 8 6.328 482.214 448.496 442.168 9.1 +Run 9 6.378 482.214 448.546 442.168 9.1 +Run 10 6.246 482.214 448.414 442.168 9.1 +Run 11 6.356 482.214 448.524 442.168 9.1 +Run 12 6.483 482.214 448.651 442.168 9.1 +Run 13 6.281 482.214 448.449 442.168 9.1 +Run 14 6.39 482.214 448.558 442.168 9.1 +Run 15 6.257 482.214 448.425 442.168 9.1 +Run 16 6.372 482.214 448.540 442.168 9.1 +Run 17 6.342 482.214 448.510 442.168 9.1 +Run 18 6.288 482.214 448.456 442.168 9.1 +Run 19 6.249 482.214 448.417 442.168 9.1 +Run 20 6.25 482.214 448.418 442.168 9.1 +Run 21 6.372 482.214 448.540 442.168 9.1 +Run 22 6.241 482.214 448.409 442.168 9.1 +Run 23 6.331 482.214 448.499 442.168 9.1 +Run 24 6.467 482.214 448.635 442.168 9.1 +Run 25 7.161 482.214 449.329 442.168 9.1 +Run 26 6.332 482.214 448.500 442.168 9.1 +Run 27 7.181 482.214 449.349 442.168 9.1 +Run 28 6.346 482.214 448.514 442.168 9.1 +Run 29 6.343 482.214 448.511 442.168 9.1 +Run 30 6.477 482.214 448.645 442.168 9.1 +Run 31 6.124 482.214 448.292 442.168 9.1 +Min 6.124 482.214 448.292 442.168 9.1 +First Quartile 6.288 482.214 448.456 442.168 9.1 +Median 6.346 482.214 448.514 442.168 9.1 +Average 6.399 482.214 448.567 442.168 9.1 +Third Quartile 6.395 482.214 448.563 442.168 9.1 +Max 7.181 482.214 449.349 442.168 9.1 diff --git a/results/out-5-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-5-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..44a0769 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 14.452 647 622.452 608 6.4 +Run 2 14.044 647 584.044 570 13.5 +Run 3 13.955 647 621.955 608 6.4 +Run 4 14.002 647 582.002 568 13.9 +Run 5 14.463 647 612.463 598 8.2 +Run 6 14.081 647 582.081 568 13.9 +Run 7 14.436 647 582.436 568 13.9 +Run 8 13.965 647 583.965 570 13.5 +Run 9 14.066 647 634.066 620 4.4 +Run 10 14.518 647 622.518 608 6.4 +Run 11 14.077 647 584.077 570 13.5 +Run 12 14.045 647 584.045 570 13.5 +Run 13 14.398 647 584.398 570 13.5 +Run 14 13.918 647 611.918 598 8.2 +Run 15 14.293 647 622.293 608 6.4 +Run 16 14.438 647 582.438 568 13.9 +Run 17 13.916 647 633.916 620 4.4 +Run 18 14.006 647 584.006 570 13.5 +Run 19 14.339 647 582.339 568 13.9 +Run 20 13.975 647 611.975 598 8.2 +Run 21 13.984 647 621.984 608 6.4 +Run 22 13.923 647 583.923 570 13.5 +Run 23 14.248 647 584.248 570 13.5 +Run 24 14.52 647 634.52 620 4.4 +Run 25 14.031 647 622.031 608 6.4 +Run 26 14.552 647 584.552 570 13.5 +Run 27 13.918 647 621.918 608 6.4 +Run 28 13.994 647 583.994 570 13.5 +Run 29 14.087 647 622.087 608 6.4 +Run 30 14.445 647 584.445 570 13.5 +Run 31 13.977 647 621.977 608 6.4 +Min 13.916 647 582.002 568 4.4 +First Quartile 13.977 647 583.994 570 6.4 +Median 14.066 647 584.552 570 13.5 +Average 14.163 647 602.421 588 10.1 +Third Quartile 14.436 647 622.031 608 13.5 +Max 14.552 647 634.52 620 13.9 diff --git a/results/out-5-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-5-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5b25bd2 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 15.397 547.188 562.559 547.162 0.0 +Run 2 14.591 547.188 561.753 547.162 0.0 +Run 3 15.112 547.188 562.274 547.162 0.0 +Run 4 15.076 547.188 562.238 547.162 0.0 +Run 5 14.885 547.188 562.047 547.162 0.0 +Run 6 14.433 547.188 561.595 547.162 0.0 +Run 7 14.537 547.188 561.699 547.162 0.0 +Run 8 14.759 547.188 561.921 547.162 0.0 +Run 9 14.584 547.188 561.746 547.162 0.0 +Run 10 14.501 547.188 561.663 547.162 0.0 +Run 11 15.028 547.188 562.190 547.162 0.0 +Run 12 14.445 547.188 561.607 547.162 0.0 +Run 13 14.489 547.188 561.651 547.162 0.0 +Run 14 14.993 547.188 562.155 547.162 0.0 +Run 15 14.513 547.188 561.675 547.162 0.0 +Run 16 14.476 547.188 561.638 547.162 0.0 +Run 17 14.75 547.188 561.912 547.162 0.0 +Run 18 14.314 547.188 561.476 547.162 0.0 +Run 19 14.963 547.188 562.125 547.162 0.0 +Run 20 14.548 547.188 561.710 547.162 0.0 +Run 21 14.392 547.188 561.554 547.162 0.0 +Run 22 14.442 547.188 561.604 547.162 0.0 +Run 23 14.601 547.188 561.763 547.162 0.0 +Run 24 14.475 547.188 561.637 547.162 0.0 +Run 25 14.837 547.188 561.999 547.162 0.0 +Run 26 15.054 547.188 562.216 547.162 0.0 +Run 27 14.72 547.188 561.882 547.162 0.0 +Run 28 14.902 547.188 562.064 547.162 0.0 +Run 29 14.611 547.188 561.773 547.162 0.0 +Run 30 14.981 547.188 562.143 547.162 0.0 +Run 31 14.404 547.188 561.566 547.162 0.0 +Min 14.314 547.188 561.476 547.162 0.0 +First Quartile 14.476 547.188 561.638 547.162 0.0 +Median 14.601 547.188 561.763 547.162 0.0 +Average 14.704 547.188 561.866 547.162 0.0 +Third Quartile 14.963 547.188 562.125 547.162 0.0 +Max 15.397 547.188 562.559 547.162 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-5-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-5-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c0b3a94 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 14.885 647 549.885 535 20.9 +Run 2 14.856 647 549.856 535 20.9 +Run 3 14.88 647 549.88 535 20.9 +Run 4 14.394 647 549.394 535 20.9 +Run 5 14.715 647 549.715 535 20.9 +Run 6 14.605 647 549.605 535 20.9 +Run 7 15.033 647 550.033 535 20.9 +Run 8 14.902 647 549.902 535 20.9 +Run 9 15.076 647 550.076 535 20.9 +Run 10 15.822 647 550.822 535 20.9 +Run 11 14.807 647 549.807 535 20.9 +Run 12 14.839 647 549.839 535 20.9 +Run 13 14.758 647 549.758 535 20.9 +Run 14 14.628 647 549.628 535 20.9 +Run 15 14.739 647 549.739 535 20.9 +Run 16 14.958 647 549.958 535 20.9 +Run 17 14.977 647 549.977 535 20.9 +Run 18 14.427 647 549.427 535 20.9 +Run 19 14.783 647 549.783 535 20.9 +Run 20 15.004 647 550.004 535 20.9 +Run 21 14.748 647 549.748 535 20.9 +Run 22 15.041 647 550.041 535 20.9 +Run 23 14.731 647 549.731 535 20.9 +Run 24 15.171 647 550.171 535 20.9 +Run 25 14.923 647 549.923 535 20.9 +Run 26 14.907 647 549.907 535 20.9 +Run 27 14.693 647 549.693 535 20.9 +Run 28 14.289 647 549.289 535 20.9 +Run 29 14.434 647 549.434 535 20.9 +Run 30 14.496 647 549.496 535 20.9 +Run 31 14.844 647 549.844 535 20.9 +Min 14.289 647 549.289 535 20.9 +First Quartile 14.693 647 549.693 535 20.9 +Median 14.839 647 549.839 535 20.9 +Average 14.818 647 549.818 535 20.9 +Third Quartile 14.958 647 549.958 535 20.9 +Max 15.822 647 550.822 535 20.9 diff --git a/results/out-5-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-5-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..df7946d --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-5-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 14.53 547.188 499.676 485.146 12.8 +Run 2 14.582 547.188 499.728 485.146 12.8 +Run 3 14.717 547.188 499.863 485.146 12.8 +Run 4 15.064 547.188 500.210 485.146 12.8 +Run 5 15.071 547.188 500.217 485.146 12.8 +Run 6 15.028 547.188 500.174 485.146 12.8 +Run 7 14.883 547.188 500.029 485.146 12.8 +Run 8 14.524 547.188 499.670 485.146 12.8 +Run 9 14.674 547.188 499.820 485.146 12.8 +Run 10 14.312 547.188 499.458 485.146 12.8 +Run 11 14.465 547.188 499.611 485.146 12.8 +Run 12 15.322 547.188 500.468 485.146 12.8 +Run 13 15.073 547.188 500.219 485.146 12.8 +Run 14 14.644 547.188 499.790 485.146 12.8 +Run 15 14.776 547.188 499.922 485.146 12.8 +Run 16 14.761 547.188 499.907 485.146 12.8 +Run 17 14.897 547.188 500.043 485.146 12.8 +Run 18 14.526 547.188 499.672 485.146 12.8 +Run 19 14.933 547.188 500.079 485.146 12.8 +Run 20 14.429 547.188 499.575 485.146 12.8 +Run 21 14.913 547.188 500.059 485.146 12.8 +Run 22 14.958 547.188 500.104 485.146 12.8 +Run 23 15.185 547.188 500.331 485.146 12.8 +Run 24 14.91 547.188 500.056 485.146 12.8 +Run 25 14.998 547.188 500.144 485.146 12.8 +Run 26 14.804 547.188 499.950 485.146 12.8 +Run 27 14.745 547.188 499.891 485.146 12.8 +Run 28 14.9 547.188 500.046 485.146 12.8 +Run 29 14.376 547.188 499.522 485.146 12.8 +Run 30 15.397 547.188 500.543 485.146 12.8 +Run 31 14.432 547.188 499.578 485.146 12.8 +Min 14.312 547.188 499.458 485.146 12.8 +First Quartile 14.53 547.188 499.676 485.146 12.8 +Median 14.804 547.188 499.950 485.146 12.8 +Average 14.801 547.188 499.947 485.146 12.8 +Third Quartile 14.998 547.188 500.144 485.146 12.8 +Max 15.397 547.188 500.543 485.146 12.8 diff --git a/results/out-6-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-6-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f3dba27 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 16.682 798 724.682 708 12.7 +Run 2 16.399 798 724.399 708 12.7 +Run 3 16.854 798 724.854 708 12.7 +Run 4 16.022 798 694.022 678 17.7 +Run 5 16.446 798 724.446 708 12.7 +Run 6 16.624 798 724.624 708 12.7 +Run 7 16.033 798 724.033 708 12.7 +Run 8 16.042 798 764.042 748 6.7 +Run 9 16.473 798 744.473 728 9.6 +Run 10 16.071 798 744.071 728 9.6 +Run 11 17.685 798 725.685 708 12.7 +Run 12 16.368 798 724.368 708 12.7 +Run 13 16.84 798 724.84 708 12.7 +Run 14 16.523 798 694.523 678 17.7 +Run 15 17.034 798 695.034 678 17.7 +Run 16 16.509 798 724.509 708 12.7 +Run 17 16.939 798 724.939 708 12.7 +Run 18 16.233 798 724.233 708 12.7 +Run 19 16.954 798 724.954 708 12.7 +Run 20 16.975 798 694.975 678 17.7 +Run 21 16.558 798 764.558 748 6.7 +Run 22 16.452 798 724.452 708 12.7 +Run 23 16.276 798 724.276 708 12.7 +Run 24 16.464 798 694.464 678 17.7 +Run 25 16.447 798 694.447 678 17.7 +Run 26 16.03 798 724.03 708 12.7 +Run 27 16.186 798 694.186 678 17.7 +Run 28 15.918 798 723.918 708 12.7 +Run 29 16.39 798 724.39 708 12.7 +Run 30 16.307 798 744.307 728 9.6 +Run 31 16.572 798 724.572 708 12.7 +Min 15.918 798 694.022 678 6.7 +First Quartile 16.233 798 723.918 708 12.7 +Median 16.452 798 724.446 708 12.7 +Average 16.494 798 722.236 706 13.1 +Third Quartile 16.682 798 724.939 708 12.7 +Max 17.685 798 764.558 748 17.7 diff --git a/results/out-6-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-6-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4a65d9d --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 16.589 542.266 488.783 472.194 14.8 +Run 2 16.236 542.266 488.430 472.194 14.8 +Run 3 16.242 542.266 488.436 472.194 14.8 +Run 4 16.466 542.266 488.660 472.194 14.8 +Run 5 16.448 542.266 488.642 472.194 14.8 +Run 6 16.186 542.266 488.380 472.194 14.8 +Run 7 16.458 542.266 488.652 472.194 14.8 +Run 8 16.535 542.266 488.729 472.194 14.8 +Run 9 16.416 542.266 488.610 472.194 14.8 +Run 10 16.299 542.266 488.493 472.194 14.8 +Run 11 16.479 542.266 488.673 472.194 14.8 +Run 12 16.515 542.266 488.709 472.194 14.8 +Run 13 16.583 542.266 488.777 472.194 14.8 +Run 14 16.087 542.266 488.281 472.194 14.8 +Run 15 15.978 542.266 488.172 472.194 14.8 +Run 16 16.346 542.266 488.540 472.194 14.8 +Run 17 16.616 542.266 488.810 472.194 14.8 +Run 18 16.432 542.266 488.626 472.194 14.8 +Run 19 16.265 542.266 488.459 472.194 14.8 +Run 20 16.494 542.266 488.688 472.194 14.8 +Run 21 16.366 542.266 488.560 472.194 14.8 +Run 22 16.241 542.266 488.435 472.194 14.8 +Run 23 16.297 542.266 488.491 472.194 14.8 +Run 24 16.165 542.266 488.359 472.194 14.8 +Run 25 16.363 542.266 488.557 472.194 14.8 +Run 26 16.317 542.266 488.511 472.194 14.8 +Run 27 16.029 542.266 488.223 472.194 14.8 +Run 28 16.498 542.266 488.692 472.194 14.8 +Run 29 18.502 542.266 490.696 472.194 14.8 +Run 30 17.011 542.266 489.205 472.194 14.8 +Run 31 17.506 542.266 489.700 472.194 14.8 +Min 15.978 542.266 488.172 472.194 14.8 +First Quartile 16.242 542.266 488.436 472.194 14.8 +Median 16.416 542.266 488.610 472.194 14.8 +Average 16.483 542.266 488.677 472.194 14.8 +Third Quartile 16.515 542.266 488.709 472.194 14.8 +Max 18.502 542.266 490.696 472.194 14.8 diff --git a/results/out-6-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-6-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e316842 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 17.581 798 765.581 748 6.7 +Run 2 15.528 798 773.528 758 5.3 +Run 3 15.806 798 763.806 748 6.7 +Run 4 15.606 798 763.606 748 6.7 +Run 5 15.522 798 753.522 738 8.1 +Run 6 15.546 798 753.546 738 8.1 +Run 7 15.517 798 763.517 748 6.7 +Run 8 16.004 798 764.004 748 6.7 +Run 9 15.954 798 763.954 748 6.7 +Run 10 15.625 798 763.625 748 6.7 +Run 11 15.945 798 753.945 738 8.1 +Run 12 15.716 798 763.716 748 6.7 +Run 13 17.398 798 755.398 738 8.1 +Run 14 16.672 798 764.672 748 6.7 +Run 15 16.546 798 754.546 738 8.1 +Run 16 15.705 798 753.705 738 8.1 +Run 17 15.826 798 763.826 748 6.7 +Run 18 16.088 798 764.088 748 6.7 +Run 19 15.569 798 763.569 748 6.7 +Run 20 16.445 798 764.445 748 6.7 +Run 21 15.711 798 753.711 738 8.1 +Run 22 15.603 798 793.603 778 2.6 +Run 23 15.795 798 763.795 748 6.7 +Run 24 15.699 798 753.699 738 8.1 +Run 25 16.275 798 764.275 748 6.7 +Run 26 15.917 798 763.917 748 6.7 +Run 27 16.63 798 754.63 738 8.1 +Run 28 18.472 798 766.472 748 6.7 +Run 29 15.764 798 763.764 748 6.7 +Run 30 15.624 798 763.624 748 6.7 +Run 31 15.469 798 763.469 748 6.7 +Min 15.469 798 753.522 738 2.6 +First Quartile 15.606 798 754.63 738 6.7 +Median 15.795 798 763.716 748 6.7 +Average 16.050 798 762.437 746 6.9 +Third Quartile 16.275 798 764.088 748 8.1 +Max 18.472 798 793.603 778 8.1 diff --git a/results/out-6-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-6-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e23ff0a --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 16.316 542.266 513.510 497.194 9.1 +Run 2 17.158 542.266 514.352 497.194 9.1 +Run 3 16.869 542.266 514.063 497.194 9.1 +Run 4 16.941 542.266 514.135 497.194 9.1 +Run 5 16.815 542.266 514.009 497.194 9.1 +Run 6 16.811 542.266 514.005 497.194 9.1 +Run 7 17.151 542.266 514.345 497.194 9.1 +Run 8 17.709 542.266 514.903 497.194 9.1 +Run 9 18.273 542.266 515.467 497.194 9.1 +Run 10 16.118 542.266 513.312 497.194 9.1 +Run 11 16.201 542.266 513.395 497.194 9.1 +Run 12 16.322 542.266 513.516 497.194 9.1 +Run 13 15.989 542.266 513.183 497.194 9.1 +Run 14 16.056 542.266 513.250 497.194 9.1 +Run 15 16.497 542.266 513.691 497.194 9.1 +Run 16 16.287 542.266 513.481 497.194 9.1 +Run 17 16.248 542.266 513.442 497.194 9.1 +Run 18 16.671 542.266 513.865 497.194 9.1 +Run 19 16.501 542.266 513.695 497.194 9.1 +Run 20 17.56 542.266 514.754 497.194 9.1 +Run 21 16.717 542.266 513.911 497.194 9.1 +Run 22 17.754 542.266 514.948 497.194 9.1 +Run 23 17.518 542.266 514.712 497.194 9.1 +Run 24 17.82 542.266 515.014 497.194 9.1 +Run 25 17.807 542.266 515.001 497.194 9.1 +Run 26 17.979 542.266 515.173 497.194 9.1 +Run 27 17.456 542.266 514.650 497.194 9.1 +Run 28 17.605 542.266 514.799 497.194 9.1 +Run 29 17.582 542.266 514.776 497.194 9.1 +Run 30 17.387 542.266 514.581 497.194 9.1 +Run 31 16.51 542.266 513.704 497.194 9.1 +Min 15.989 542.266 513.183 497.194 9.1 +First Quartile 16.322 542.266 513.516 497.194 9.1 +Median 16.869 542.266 514.063 497.194 9.1 +Average 16.988 542.266 514.182 497.194 9.1 +Third Quartile 17.582 542.266 514.776 497.194 9.1 +Max 18.273 542.266 515.467 497.194 9.1 diff --git a/results/out-6-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-6-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..102e6f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 38.847 635 673.847 635 0.0 +Run 2 38.209 635 673.209 635 0.0 +Run 3 38.308 635 673.308 635 0.0 +Run 4 38.32 635 673.32 635 0.0 +Run 5 38.486 635 673.486 635 0.0 +Run 6 38.11 635 673.11 635 0.0 +Run 7 38.008 635 673.008 635 0.0 +Run 8 37.529 635 672.529 635 0.0 +Run 9 38.667 635 673.667 635 0.0 +Run 10 37.796 635 672.796 635 0.0 +Run 11 38.117 635 673.117 635 0.0 +Run 12 39.079 635 674.079 635 0.0 +Run 13 38.486 635 673.486 635 0.0 +Run 14 39.307 635 674.307 635 0.0 +Run 15 39.203 635 674.203 635 0.0 +Run 16 45.132 635 680.132 635 0.0 +Run 17 37.518 635 672.518 635 0.0 +Run 18 38.437 635 673.437 635 0.0 +Run 19 38.563 635 673.563 635 0.0 +Run 20 38.035 635 673.035 635 0.0 +Run 21 37.496 635 672.496 635 0.0 +Run 22 37.965 635 672.965 635 0.0 +Run 23 38.632 635 673.632 635 0.0 +Run 24 38.633 635 673.633 635 0.0 +Run 25 38.365 635 673.365 635 0.0 +Run 26 37.627 635 672.627 635 0.0 +Run 27 37.213 635 672.213 635 0.0 +Run 28 39.193 635 674.193 635 0.0 +Run 29 39.063 635 674.063 635 0.0 +Run 30 37.979 635 672.979 635 0.0 +Run 31 38.78 635 673.78 635 0.0 +Min 37.213 635 672.213 635 0.0 +First Quartile 37.979 635 672.979 635 0.0 +Median 38.365 635 673.365 635 0.0 +Average 38.552 635 673.552 635 0.0 +Third Quartile 38.78 635 673.78 635 0.0 +Max 45.132 635 680.132 635 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-6-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-6-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..da9c9c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 38.801 570.202 481.997 443.196 28.7 +Run 2 37.313 570.202 480.509 443.196 28.7 +Run 3 37.9 570.202 481.096 443.196 28.7 +Run 4 38.434 570.202 481.630 443.196 28.7 +Run 5 38.272 570.202 481.468 443.196 28.7 +Run 6 38.469 570.202 481.665 443.196 28.7 +Run 7 37.866 570.202 481.062 443.196 28.7 +Run 8 38.257 570.202 481.453 443.196 28.7 +Run 9 37.879 570.202 481.075 443.196 28.7 +Run 10 37.101 570.202 480.297 443.196 28.7 +Run 11 37.415 570.202 480.611 443.196 28.7 +Run 12 38.718 570.202 481.914 443.196 28.7 +Run 13 38.266 570.202 481.462 443.196 28.7 +Run 14 38.487 570.202 481.683 443.196 28.7 +Run 15 37.585 570.202 480.781 443.196 28.7 +Run 16 37.966 570.202 481.162 443.196 28.7 +Run 17 37.962 570.202 481.158 443.196 28.7 +Run 18 37.189 570.202 480.385 443.196 28.7 +Run 19 38.799 570.202 481.995 443.196 28.7 +Run 20 38.077 570.202 481.273 443.196 28.7 +Run 21 38.298 570.202 481.494 443.196 28.7 +Run 22 39.272 570.202 482.468 443.196 28.7 +Run 23 38.044 570.202 481.240 443.196 28.7 +Run 24 38.249 570.202 481.445 443.196 28.7 +Run 25 37.445 570.202 480.641 443.196 28.7 +Run 26 37.104 570.202 480.300 443.196 28.7 +Run 27 38.363 570.202 481.559 443.196 28.7 +Run 28 37.587 570.202 480.783 443.196 28.7 +Run 29 38.422 570.202 481.618 443.196 28.7 +Run 30 37.264 570.202 480.460 443.196 28.7 +Run 31 37.891 570.202 481.087 443.196 28.7 +Min 37.101 570.202 480.297 443.196 28.7 +First Quartile 37.585 570.202 480.781 443.196 28.7 +Median 38.044 570.202 481.240 443.196 28.7 +Average 38.022 570.202 481.218 443.196 28.7 +Third Quartile 38.422 570.202 481.618 443.196 28.7 +Max 39.272 570.202 482.468 443.196 28.7 diff --git a/results/out-6-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-6-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5bc47fd --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 38.354 635 673.354 635 0.0 +Run 2 38.687 635 673.687 635 0.0 +Run 3 38.273 635 673.273 635 0.0 +Run 4 38.417 635 673.417 635 0.0 +Run 5 38.394 635 673.394 635 0.0 +Run 6 36.926 635 671.926 635 0.0 +Run 7 38.77 635 673.77 635 0.0 +Run 8 38.536 635 673.536 635 0.0 +Run 9 38.563 635 673.563 635 0.0 +Run 10 39.004 635 674.004 635 0.0 +Run 11 37.79 635 672.79 635 0.0 +Run 12 37.594 635 672.594 635 0.0 +Run 13 38.055 635 673.055 635 0.0 +Run 14 37.097 635 672.097 635 0.0 +Run 15 37.528 635 672.528 635 0.0 +Run 16 38.348 635 673.348 635 0.0 +Run 17 37.629 635 672.629 635 0.0 +Run 18 37.27 635 672.27 635 0.0 +Run 19 37.15 635 672.15 635 0.0 +Run 20 38.689 635 673.689 635 0.0 +Run 21 39.061 635 674.061 635 0.0 +Run 22 37.066 635 672.066 635 0.0 +Run 23 38.483 635 673.483 635 0.0 +Run 24 38.155 635 673.155 635 0.0 +Run 25 37.102 635 672.102 635 0.0 +Run 26 37.536 635 672.536 635 0.0 +Run 27 38.338 635 673.338 635 0.0 +Run 28 37.951 635 672.951 635 0.0 +Run 29 37.544 635 672.544 635 0.0 +Run 30 38.339 635 673.339 635 0.0 +Run 31 38.933 635 673.933 635 0.0 +Min 36.926 635 671.926 635 0.0 +First Quartile 37.536 635 672.536 635 0.0 +Median 38.273 635 673.273 635 0.0 +Average 38.051 635 673.051 635 0.0 +Third Quartile 38.536 635 673.536 635 0.0 +Max 39.061 635 674.061 635 0.0 diff --git a/results/out-6-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-6-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..797afde --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-6-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 42.216 570.202 550.390 508.174 12.2 +Run 2 38.514 570.202 546.688 508.174 12.2 +Run 3 44.063 570.202 604.235 560.172 1.8 +Run 4 38.097 570.202 598.269 560.172 1.8 +Run 5 45.087 570.202 553.261 508.174 12.2 +Run 6 43.647 570.202 551.821 508.174 12.2 +Run 7 37.953 570.202 546.127 508.174 12.2 +Run 8 38.12 570.202 546.294 508.174 12.2 +Run 9 38.162 570.202 546.336 508.174 12.2 +Run 10 38.15 570.202 546.324 508.174 12.2 +Run 11 38.449 570.202 546.623 508.174 12.2 +Run 12 37.391 570.202 545.565 508.174 12.2 +Run 13 37.156 570.202 545.330 508.174 12.2 +Run 14 37.567 570.202 545.741 508.174 12.2 +Run 15 37.691 570.202 545.865 508.174 12.2 +Run 16 37.258 570.202 545.432 508.174 12.2 +Run 17 38.166 570.202 546.340 508.174 12.2 +Run 18 38.51 570.202 546.684 508.174 12.2 +Run 19 38.438 570.202 546.612 508.174 12.2 +Run 20 38.352 570.202 546.526 508.174 12.2 +Run 21 37.63 570.202 545.804 508.174 12.2 +Run 22 36.962 570.202 545.136 508.174 12.2 +Run 23 38.876 570.202 547.050 508.174 12.2 +Run 24 38.789 570.202 546.963 508.174 12.2 +Run 25 38.493 570.202 546.667 508.174 12.2 +Run 26 38.582 570.202 546.756 508.174 12.2 +Run 27 38.694 570.202 546.868 508.174 12.2 +Run 28 38.198 570.202 546.372 508.174 12.2 +Run 29 38.591 570.202 546.765 508.174 12.2 +Run 30 37.49 570.202 545.664 508.174 12.2 +Run 31 38.098 570.202 546.272 508.174 12.2 +Min 36.962 570.202 545.136 508.174 1.8 +First Quartile 37.691 570.202 545.865 508.174 12.2 +Median 38.198 570.202 546.526 508.174 12.2 +Average 38.819 570.202 550.348 511.529 11.5 +Third Quartile 38.591 570.202 546.868 508.174 12.2 +Max 45.087 570.202 604.235 560.172 12.2 diff --git a/results/out-7-false-false-false.csv b/results/out-7-false-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d3231a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-false-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 126.748 1660 1539.748 1413 17.5 +Run 2 126.391 1660 1399.391 1273 30.4 +Run 3 134.798 1660 1407.798 1273 30.4 +Run 4 130.123 1660 1403.123 1273 30.4 +Run 5 126.743 1660 1575.743 1449 14.6 +Run 6 136.471 1660 1409.471 1273 30.4 +Run 7 125.114 1660 1418.114 1293 28.4 +Run 8 125.177 1660 1673.177 1548 7.2 +Run 9 130.05 1660 1383.05 1253 32.5 +Run 10 131.687 1660 1610.687 1479 12.2 +Run 11 128.95 1660 1453.95 1325 25.3 +Run 12 130.542 1660 1589.542 1459 13.8 +Run 13 129.798 1660 1422.798 1293 28.4 +Run 14 126.697 1660 1539.697 1413 17.5 +Run 15 126.865 1660 1563.865 1437 15.5 +Run 16 129.078 1660 1402.078 1273 30.4 +Run 17 128.298 1660 1561.298 1433 15.8 +Run 18 125.35 1660 1574.35 1449 14.6 +Run 19 135.158 1660 1584.158 1449 14.6 +Run 20 127.342 1660 1400.342 1273 30.4 +Run 21 127.545 1660 1380.545 1253 32.5 +Run 22 125.798 1660 1604.798 1479 12.2 +Run 23 129.076 1660 1578.076 1449 14.6 +Run 24 126.523 1660 1399.523 1273 30.4 +Run 25 125.323 1660 1574.323 1449 14.6 +Run 26 127.522 1660 1550.522 1423 16.7 +Run 27 126.731 1660 1585.731 1459 13.8 +Run 28 126.725 1660 1399.725 1273 30.4 +Run 29 126.808 1660 1575.808 1449 14.6 +Run 30 126.743 1660 1585.743 1459 13.8 +Run 31 127.742 1660 1400.742 1273 30.4 +Min 125.114 1660 1380.545 1253 7.2 +First Quartile 126.697 1660 1402.078 1273 14.6 +Median 127.342 1660 1539.748 1413 17.5 +Average 128.320 1660 1501.546 1373 21.4 +Third Quartile 129.798 1660 1578.076 1449 30.4 +Max 136.471 1660 1673.177 1548 32.5 diff --git a/results/out-7-false-false-true.csv b/results/out-7-false-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dce5844 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-false-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 126.545 1192.436 1152.873 1026.328 16.2 +Run 2 126.708 1192.436 1153.036 1026.328 16.2 +Run 3 126.681 1192.436 1153.009 1026.328 16.2 +Run 4 125.448 1192.436 1151.776 1026.328 16.2 +Run 5 135.478 1192.436 1161.806 1026.328 16.2 +Run 6 142.207 1192.436 1168.535 1026.328 16.2 +Run 7 134.198 1192.436 1160.526 1026.328 16.2 +Run 8 130.739 1192.436 1157.067 1026.328 16.2 +Run 9 134.723 1192.436 1161.051 1026.328 16.2 +Run 10 133.516 1192.436 1159.844 1026.328 16.2 +Run 11 135.387 1192.436 1161.715 1026.328 16.2 +Run 12 132.294 1192.436 1158.622 1026.328 16.2 +Run 13 134.031 1192.436 1160.359 1026.328 16.2 +Run 14 135.458 1192.436 1161.786 1026.328 16.2 +Run 15 134.115 1192.436 1160.443 1026.328 16.2 +Run 16 133.011 1192.436 1159.339 1026.328 16.2 +Run 17 132.785 1192.436 1159.113 1026.328 16.2 +Run 18 132.086 1192.436 1158.414 1026.328 16.2 +Run 19 133.706 1192.436 1160.034 1026.328 16.2 +Run 20 174.825 1192.436 1201.153 1026.328 16.2 +Run 21 169.79 1192.436 1196.118 1026.328 16.2 +Run 22 144.059 1192.436 1170.387 1026.328 16.2 +Run 23 144.035 1192.436 1055.369 911.334 30.8 +Run 24 142.047 1192.436 1168.375 1026.328 16.2 +Run 25 143.425 1192.436 1169.753 1026.328 16.2 +Run 26 141.74 1192.436 1168.068 1026.328 16.2 +Run 27 141.634 1192.436 1167.962 1026.328 16.2 +Run 28 143.365 1192.436 1169.693 1026.328 16.2 +Run 29 143.735 1192.436 1170.063 1026.328 16.2 +Run 30 140.841 1192.436 1167.169 1026.328 16.2 +Run 31 140.057 1192.436 1166.385 1026.328 16.2 +Min 125.448 1192.436 1055.369 911.334 16.2 +First Quartile 132.785 1192.436 1158.622 1026.328 16.2 +Median 135.387 1192.436 1161.051 1026.328 16.2 +Average 138.344 1192.436 1160.963 1022.619 16.7 +Third Quartile 142.207 1192.436 1168.375 1026.328 16.2 +Max 174.825 1192.436 1201.153 1026.328 30.8 diff --git a/results/out-7-false-true-false.csv b/results/out-7-false-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bf85dda --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-false-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 126.672 1660 1550.672 1424 16.6 +Run 2 133.888 1660 1557.888 1424 16.6 +Run 3 125.233 1660 1549.233 1424 16.6 +Run 4 125.522 1660 1467.522 1342 23.7 +Run 5 131.872 1660 1555.872 1424 16.6 +Run 6 127.874 1660 1551.874 1424 16.6 +Run 7 126.578 1660 1550.578 1424 16.6 +Run 8 126.669 1660 1550.669 1424 16.6 +Run 9 126.736 1660 1550.736 1424 16.6 +Run 10 126.299 1660 1550.299 1424 16.6 +Run 11 131.34 1660 1555.34 1424 16.6 +Run 12 125.215 1660 1549.215 1424 16.6 +Run 13 126.55 1660 1550.55 1424 16.6 +Run 14 156.805 1660 1498.805 1342 23.7 +Run 15 125.715 1660 1549.715 1424 16.6 +Run 16 126.109 1660 1468.109 1342 23.7 +Run 17 124.832 1660 1548.832 1424 16.6 +Run 18 125.826 1660 1467.826 1342 23.7 +Run 19 127.099 1660 1469.099 1342 23.7 +Run 20 123.774 1660 1475.774 1352 22.8 +Run 21 128.213 1660 1470.213 1342 23.7 +Run 22 123.124 1660 1465.124 1342 23.7 +Run 23 124.695 1660 1538.695 1414 17.4 +Run 24 126.816 1660 1478.816 1352 22.8 +Run 25 133.087 1660 1557.087 1424 16.6 +Run 26 124.98 1660 1548.98 1424 16.6 +Run 27 124.851 1660 1476.851 1352 22.8 +Run 28 123.844 1660 1465.844 1342 23.7 +Run 29 124.096 1660 1548.096 1424 16.6 +Run 30 124.559 1660 1548.559 1424 16.6 +Run 31 126.399 1660 1550.399 1424 16.6 +Min 123.124 1660 1465.124 1342 16.6 +First Quartile 124.851 1660 1475.774 1342 16.6 +Median 126.299 1660 1548.98 1424 16.6 +Average 127.589 1660 1523.138 1396 19.1 +Third Quartile 127.099 1660 1550.669 1424 23.7 +Max 156.805 1660 1557.888 1424 23.7 diff --git a/results/out-7-false-true-true.csv b/results/out-7-false-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3461608 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-false-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 140.707 1192.436 1152.031 1011.324 17.9 +Run 2 255.255 1192.436 1266.579 1011.324 17.9 +Run 3 125.499 1192.436 1136.823 1011.324 17.9 +Run 4 126.177 1192.436 1137.501 1011.324 17.9 +Run 5 127.294 1192.436 1138.618 1011.324 17.9 +Run 6 127.873 1192.436 1139.197 1011.324 17.9 +Run 7 130.016 1192.436 1141.340 1011.324 17.9 +Run 8 125.702 1192.436 1137.026 1011.324 17.9 +Run 9 125.384 1192.436 1136.708 1011.324 17.9 +Run 10 123.828 1192.436 1135.152 1011.324 17.9 +Run 11 127.252 1192.436 1138.576 1011.324 17.9 +Run 12 125.846 1192.436 1137.170 1011.324 17.9 +Run 13 125.567 1192.436 1136.891 1011.324 17.9 +Run 14 125.52 1192.436 1136.844 1011.324 17.9 +Run 15 126.358 1192.436 1137.682 1011.324 17.9 +Run 16 127.687 1192.436 1139.011 1011.324 17.9 +Run 17 124.993 1192.436 1136.317 1011.324 17.9 +Run 18 126.329 1192.436 1137.653 1011.324 17.9 +Run 19 125.466 1192.436 1136.790 1011.324 17.9 +Run 20 125.438 1192.436 1136.762 1011.324 17.9 +Run 21 124.326 1192.436 1135.650 1011.324 17.9 +Run 22 124.779 1192.436 1136.103 1011.324 17.9 +Run 23 127.688 1192.436 1139.012 1011.324 17.9 +Run 24 126.58 1192.436 1137.904 1011.324 17.9 +Run 25 124.375 1192.436 1135.699 1011.324 17.9 +Run 26 124.958 1192.436 1136.278 1011.320 17.9 +Run 27 125.291 1192.436 1136.615 1011.324 17.9 +Run 28 125.193 1192.436 1136.517 1011.324 17.9 +Run 29 124.92 1192.436 1136.244 1011.324 17.9 +Run 30 126.53 1192.436 1137.854 1011.324 17.9 +Run 31 124.778 1192.436 1136.102 1011.324 17.9 +Min 123.828 1192.436 1135.152 1011.320 17.9 +First Quartile 124.993 1192.436 1136.317 1011.324 17.9 +Median 125.567 1192.436 1136.891 1011.324 17.9 +Average 130.568 1192.436 1141.892 1011.324 17.9 +Third Quartile 127.252 1192.436 1138.576 1011.324 17.9 +Max 255.255 1192.436 1266.579 1011.324 17.9 diff --git a/results/out-7-true-false-false.csv b/results/out-7-true-false-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..12167c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-true-false-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 433.178 983 1231.178 798 23.2 +Run 2 438.909 983 1256.909 818 20.2 +Run 3 436.063 983 1234.063 798 23.2 +Run 4 434.398 983 1232.398 798 23.2 +Run 5 434.832 983 1232.832 798 23.2 +Run 6 434.265 983 1252.265 818 20.2 +Run 7 436.926 983 1254.926 818 20.2 +Run 8 443.814 983 1241.814 798 23.2 +Run 9 437.382 983 1235.382 798 23.2 +Run 10 439.383 983 1247.383 808 21.7 +Run 11 439.635 983 1237.635 798 23.2 +Run 12 437.903 983 1235.903 798 23.2 +Run 13 441.499 983 1259.499 818 20.2 +Run 14 445.303 983 1243.303 798 23.2 +Run 15 436.304 983 1234.304 798 23.2 +Run 16 434.29 983 1232.29 798 23.2 +Run 17 458.338 983 1256.338 798 23.2 +Run 18 436.956 983 1234.956 798 23.2 +Run 19 434.298 983 1232.298 798 23.2 +Run 20 434.223 983 1252.223 818 20.2 +Run 21 440.847 983 1238.847 798 23.2 +Run 22 437.037 983 1235.037 798 23.2 +Run 23 434.13 983 1232.13 798 23.2 +Run 24 435.844 983 1253.844 818 20.2 +Run 25 440.318 983 1238.318 798 23.2 +Run 26 437.081 983 1335.081 898 9.5 +Run 27 435.253 983 1233.253 798 23.2 +Run 28 436.587 983 1234.587 798 23.2 +Run 29 448.99 983 1266.99 818 20.2 +Run 30 511.848 983 1399.848 888 10.7 +Run 31 538.898 983 1356.898 818 20.2 +Min 433.178 983 1231.178 798 9.5 +First Quartile 434.832 983 1234.063 798 20.2 +Median 437.037 983 1238.318 798 23.2 +Average 444.024 983 1253.637 810 21.5 +Third Quartile 440.847 983 1254.926 818 23.2 +Max 538.898 983 1399.848 898 23.2 diff --git a/results/out-7-true-false-true.csv b/results/out-7-true-false-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fb32fa0 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-true-false-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 535.727 828.284 1068.971 533.244 55.3 +Run 2 493.218 828.284 1026.462 533.244 55.3 +Run 3 429.803 828.284 963.047 533.244 55.3 +Run 4 438.025 828.284 971.269 533.244 55.3 +Run 5 437.993 828.284 971.237 533.244 55.3 +Run 6 431.971 828.284 965.215 533.244 55.3 +Run 7 429.845 828.284 963.089 533.244 55.3 +Run 8 431.362 828.284 964.606 533.244 55.3 +Run 9 435.973 828.284 969.217 533.244 55.3 +Run 10 432.591 828.284 965.835 533.244 55.3 +Run 11 437.188 828.284 970.432 533.244 55.3 +Run 12 432.588 828.284 965.832 533.244 55.3 +Run 13 435.664 828.284 968.908 533.244 55.3 +Run 14 435.625 828.284 968.869 533.244 55.3 +Run 15 434.472 828.284 967.716 533.244 55.3 +Run 16 438.385 828.284 971.629 533.244 55.3 +Run 17 436.633 828.284 969.877 533.244 55.3 +Run 18 434.958 828.284 968.202 533.244 55.3 +Run 19 428.712 828.284 961.956 533.244 55.3 +Run 20 434.141 828.284 967.385 533.244 55.3 +Run 21 437.702 828.284 970.946 533.244 55.3 +Run 22 438.029 828.284 971.273 533.244 55.3 +Run 23 436.897 828.284 970.141 533.244 55.3 +Run 24 430.501 828.284 963.745 533.244 55.3 +Run 25 427.455 828.284 960.699 533.244 55.3 +Run 26 439.058 828.284 972.302 533.244 55.3 +Run 27 433.854 828.284 967.098 533.244 55.3 +Run 28 432.309 828.284 965.553 533.244 55.3 +Run 29 435.436 828.284 968.680 533.244 55.3 +Run 30 462.049 828.284 995.293 533.244 55.3 +Run 31 431.294 828.284 964.538 533.244 55.3 +Min 427.455 828.284 960.699 533.244 55.3 +First Quartile 431.971 828.284 965.215 533.244 55.3 +Median 435.436 828.284 968.680 533.244 55.3 +Average 440.305 828.284 973.549 533.244 55.3 +Third Quartile 437.993 828.284 971.237 533.244 55.3 +Max 535.727 828.284 1068.971 533.244 55.3 diff --git a/results/out-7-true-true-false.csv b/results/out-7-true-true-false.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fe1c4d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-true-true-false.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 506.209 983 1375.209 869 13.1 +Run 2 443.424 983 1364.424 921 6.7 +Run 3 442.914 983 1353.914 911 7.9 +Run 4 435.311 983 1346.311 911 7.9 +Run 5 436.351 983 1305.351 869 13.1 +Run 6 439.013 983 1350.013 911 7.9 +Run 7 436.621 983 1285.621 849 15.8 +Run 8 434.599 983 1355.599 921 6.7 +Run 9 438.084 983 1349.084 911 7.9 +Run 10 438.53 983 1307.53 869 13.1 +Run 11 474.502 983 1323.502 849 15.8 +Run 12 435.734 983 1346.734 911 7.9 +Run 13 481.879 983 1350.879 869 13.1 +Run 14 464.285 983 1375.285 911 7.9 +Run 15 435.477 983 1284.477 849 15.8 +Run 16 439.075 983 1308.075 869 13.1 +Run 17 443.404 983 1312.404 869 13.1 +Run 18 434.562 983 1417.562 983 0.0 +Run 19 436.13 983 1347.13 911 7.9 +Run 20 456.066 983 1367.066 911 7.9 +Run 21 448.224 983 1359.224 911 7.9 +Run 22 448.972 983 1317.972 869 13.1 +Run 23 450.495 983 1319.495 869 13.1 +Run 24 577.865 983 1560.865 983 0.0 +Run 25 585.781 983 1454.781 869 13.1 +Run 26 554.156 983 1423.156 869 13.1 +Run 27 455.748 983 1324.748 869 13.1 +Run 28 452.107 983 1321.107 869 13.1 +Run 29 452.071 983 1321.071 869 13.1 +Run 30 450.819 983 1433.819 983 0.0 +Run 31 450.606 983 1361.606 911 7.9 +Min 434.562 983 1284.477 849 0.0 +First Quartile 436.621 983 1319.495 869 7.9 +Median 448.224 983 1349.084 869 13.1 +Average 460.613 983 1355.613 895 10.0 +Third Quartile 456.066 983 1367.066 911 13.1 +Max 585.781 983 1560.865 983 15.8 diff --git a/results/out-7-true-true-true.csv b/results/out-7-true-true-true.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e892ffe --- /dev/null +++ b/results/out-7-true-true-true.csv @@ -0,0 +1,37 @@ +Run 1 450.384 828.284 1240.622 790.238 4.8 +Run 2 478.128 828.284 1268.366 790.238 4.8 +Run 3 454.841 828.284 1245.079 790.238 4.8 +Run 4 473.512 828.284 1263.750 790.238 4.8 +Run 5 450.955 828.284 1241.193 790.238 4.8 +Run 6 454.581 828.284 1244.819 790.238 4.8 +Run 7 452.496 828.284 1242.734 790.238 4.8 +Run 8 449.792 828.284 1240.030 790.238 4.8 +Run 9 447.903 828.284 1238.141 790.238 4.8 +Run 10 454.008 828.284 1244.246 790.238 4.8 +Run 11 446.861 828.284 1237.099 790.238 4.8 +Run 12 449.517 828.284 1239.755 790.238 4.8 +Run 13 453.459 828.284 1243.697 790.238 4.8 +Run 14 450.428 828.284 1240.666 790.238 4.8 +Run 15 450.876 828.284 1241.114 790.238 4.8 +Run 16 447.369 828.284 1237.607 790.238 4.8 +Run 17 456.317 828.284 1246.555 790.238 4.8 +Run 18 453.512 828.284 1243.750 790.238 4.8 +Run 19 453.253 828.284 1243.491 790.238 4.8 +Run 20 450.093 828.284 1240.331 790.238 4.8 +Run 21 451.578 828.284 1241.816 790.238 4.8 +Run 22 451.977 828.284 1242.215 790.238 4.8 +Run 23 456.059 828.284 1246.297 790.238 4.8 +Run 24 449.089 828.284 1239.327 790.238 4.8 +Run 25 446.614 828.284 1236.852 790.238 4.8 +Run 26 452.989 828.284 1243.227 790.238 4.8 +Run 27 449.831 828.284 1240.069 790.238 4.8 +Run 28 450.335 828.284 1240.573 790.238 4.8 +Run 29 447.998 828.284 1238.236 790.238 4.8 +Run 30 448.06 828.284 1238.298 790.238 4.8 +Run 31 445.334 828.284 1235.572 790.238 4.8 +Min 445.334 828.284 1235.572 790.238 4.8 +First Quartile 449.089 828.284 1239.327 790.238 4.8 +Median 450.876 828.284 1241.114 790.238 4.8 +Average 452.521 828.284 1242.759 790.238 4.8 +Third Quartile 453.512 828.284 1243.750 790.238 4.8 +Max 478.128 828.284 1268.366 790.238 4.8 diff --git a/transformations/README.MD b/transformations/README.MD new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e1b5dcd --- /dev/null +++ b/transformations/README.MD @@ -0,0 +1,460 @@ +The following rules have been applied in order to create PDDL files from IEC 62264 production system models. + +# PDDL Domain Definitions + +## Metamodel Concepts +Metamodel concepts of IEC 62264 are being converted to a set of PDDL type specifications and predicates. Relevant elements are those that appear within a given IEC 62264 model. Unused elements are not translated in order to reduce file size and increase performance and readability. +* IEC 62264 elements (e.g., `Equipment`, `Equipment Class`) are converted to types. +* IEC 62264 relations (e.g., `Equipment` can be classified by [0..*] `Equipment Classes`) are converted to predicates. + +For the above mentioned examples, the IEC 62264 concepts are translated from +```mermaid +classDiagram + Person "0..*" --> "0..*" Personnel Class : defined by + Equipment "0..*" --> "0..*" Equipment Class : defined by + Material Lot "0..*" --> "1" Material Definition : defined by + Material Definition "0..*" --> "0..*" Material Class : grouped by +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:types + PersonnelClass Person + EquipmentClass Equipment + MaterialClass MaterialDefinition MaterialLot +) +(:predicates + (PersonClassed ?P - Person ?C - PersonnelClass) + (EquipmentClassed ?E - Equipment ?C - EquipmentClass) + (MaterialClassed ?D - MaterialDefinition ?C - MaterialClass) + (MaterialDefined ?L - MaterialLot ?D - MaterialDefinition) + (MaterialLotClassed ?L - MaterialLot ?C - MaterialClass) +) +``` +Where the last predicate `(MaterialLotClassed ?L - MaterialLot ?C - MaterialClass)` is the composition of `defined by` and `grouped by` in the material information model. + +## Model Concepts +IEC 62264 instance data is converted into PDDL information using the rules laid out in the following clauses. Note, that we are using class diagram visual syntax instead of object diagram syntax due to limitations in the used Markdown rendering engine. + +### * Class and Material Definition +`* Class` and `Material Definition` instances are converted to constants + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class MaintenanceEngineer + <> MaintenanceEngineer + class PositioningUnit + <> PositioningUnit + class Chassis + <> Chassis + class ChassisBlack + <> ChassisBlack +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:constants + PC_MaintenanceEngineer - PersonnelClass + EC_PositioningUnit - EquipmentClass + MC_Chassis - MaterialClass + MD_Chassis-Black - MaterialDefinition +) +``` + +### * Class Property and Material Definition Property +Boolean `* Class Property` and `Material Definition Property` instances are converted to predicates and actions. Non-boolean properties are not supported in the current state of implementation. The actions are only generated, if the property is not marked as of kind `implicit`, in which case the corresponding predicate is only triggered by other actions' effects. + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class PositioningUnit + <> PositioningUnit + class Locked + <> Locked + PositioningUnit *-- Locked : has property +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:predicates + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E - Equipment) +) + +(:action LockPositioningUnit + :parameters (?E - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?E EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?E)) + ) + :effect + (and + (increase (total-cost) 1) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E) + ) +) + +(:action UnlockPositioningUnit + :parameters (?E - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?E EC_PositioningUnit) + (PositioningUnitLocked ?E) + ) + :effect + (and + (increase (total-cost) 1) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?E)) + ) +) +``` +Please, note that we have applied hard-coded "pretty-printing" to some of the `* Class Property` instances. In the above case `PositioningUnit`'s `locked` is translated into the terms `LockPositioningUnit` and `UnlockPositioningUnit`. The default translation for this instance would be `PositioningUnitLockedTrue` `PositioningUnitLockedFalse`. Action cost for setting a property are considered to be 1. + +### Resource Network Connection Type +`Resource Network Connection Type` instances are converted to predicates. + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class EquipmentReachTo + <> EquipmentReachTo + class MaterialLocation + <> MaterialLocation +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:predicates + (ReachesTo ?R ?E - Equipment) + (MaterialLocation ?M - MaterialLot ?E - Equipment) +) +``` + +Please, note that we have applied hard-coded "pretty-printing" to some of the `ResourceNetworkConnectionType` instances. In the above case `EquipmentReachTo` is translated into the term `ReachesTo`. + +### Process Segment +`Process Segment` instances are converted to actions, with their `* Segment Specification` instances becoming their parameters and being used in certain pre and post condition statements. In the example below, we are not listing all elements specified in the IEC 62264 input model, as this would increase complexity a lot. Instead, we are listing the main elements of the input model, but we are listing the complete result for the PDDL domain description. + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class MoveShuttle + <> MoveShuttle + class SHUTTLE + <> SHUTTLE + class Shuttle + <> Shuttle + class FROM + <> FROM + class TO + <> TO + class LockedFrom { + <> + description = "pddl:pre" + value = false + } + class PositioningUnit + <> PositioningUnit + class TransportationNode + <> TransportationNode + class LockedTo { + <> + description = "pddl:pre" + value = false + } + class Locked + <> Locked + MoveShuttle *-- SHUTTLE : contains + MoveShuttle *-- FROM : contains + MoveShuttle *-- TO : contains + SHUTTLE --> Shuttle : specifies + FROM *-- LockedFrom : has property + FROM --> PositioningUnit : specifies + FROM --> TransportationNode : specifies + TO --> PositioningUnit : specifies + TO --> TransportationNode : specifies + TO *-- LockedTo : has property + PositioningUnit *-- Locked : has property + LockedFrom --> Locked : corresponds to + LockedTo --> Locked : corresponds to +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:action MoveShuttle + :parameters (?SHUTTLE ?FROM ?TO - Equipment) + :precondition + (and + (EquipmentClassed ?SHUTTLE EC_Shuttle) + (or + (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_TransportationNode) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?FROM EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?FROM)) + ) + (or + (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_PositioningUnit) + (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_TransportationNode) + ) + (imply (EquipmentClassed ?TO EC_PositioningUnit) + (not (PositioningUnitLocked ?TO)) + ) + (TransportationNodeConnection ?FROM ?TO) + (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?FROM) + (not (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?TO)) + ) + :effect + (and + (increase (total-cost) (shuttle-time ?FROM ?TO)) + (not (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?FROM)) + (EquipmentLocation ?SHUTTLE ?TO) + ) +) +``` + +Please, note that we are adding a few pre- and post conditions hard-coded in the transformation process, based on our knowledge of the underlying production system, e.g., utilization of the `EquipmentLocation` and `TransportationNodeConnection` predicates. + +Further, the action cost are encoded as a function `shuttle-time` that is filled with values in the PDDL problem description. + +# PDDL Problem Definitions + +## Person, Equipment, and Material Lot +Instances of `Person`, `Equipment`, and `Material Lot` are converted to objects. Their relations to `* Class` or `Material Definition` instances are materialized as initialization statements. + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class MaintenanceEngineer1 + <> MaintenanceEngineer1 + class MaintenanceEngineer + <> MaintenanceEngineer + class Shuttle1 + <> Shuttle1 + class Shuttle + <> Shuttle + class ChassisBlack1 + <> ChassisBlack1 + class ChassisBlack + <> ChassisBlack + class Chassis + <> Chassis + MaintenanceEngineer1 --> MaintenanceEngineer : defined by + Shuttle1 --> Shuttle : defined by + ChassisBlack1 --> ChassisBlack : defined by + ChassisBlack --> Chassis : grouped by +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:objects + P_MaintenanceEngineer-1 - Person + E_Shuttle-1 - Equipment + ML_Chassis-Black-1 - MaterialLot +) +(:init + (PersonClassed P_MaintenanceEngineer-1 PC_MaintenanceEngineer) + (EquipmentClassed E_Shuttle-1 EC_Shuttle) + (MaterialClassed MD_Chassis-Black MC_Chassis) + (MaterialDefined ML_Chassis-Black-1 MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialLotClassed ML_Chassis-Black-1 MC_Chassis) +) +``` + +## Resource Network Connection +`Resource Network Connection` instances are converted to init statements, except for goal description models, where they are converted to goal statements. + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class Robot1ReachesToTable1 + <> Robot1ReachesToTable1 + class Robot1ReachesToPUMC1 + <> Robot1ReachesToPUMC1 + class Robot1ReachesToPUMC2 + <> Robot1ReachesToPUMC2 + class EquipmentReachTo + <> EquipmentReachTo + Robot1ReachesToTable1 --> EquipmentReachTo : derived from + Robot1ReachesToPUMC1 --> EquipmentReachTo : derived from + Robot1ReachesToPUMC2 --> EquipmentReachTo : derived from +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:init + (ReachesTo E_Robot-1 E_Table-1) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (ReachesTo E_Robot-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) +) +``` + +## Intralogistic Routing Topology +`Resource Network Connection` instances of type `Transport-System-Track-Connection` and `Transport-System-Positioning-Unit-Connection` are converted in a very specific way. The former raw connections represent the physical connections of all track curves, lines, and switches. The latter represent the physical location where a positioning unit has been attached to a track. This information is read in, and a directed graph structure is generated. Here, we already show a simplified graph where only topologically important elements are kept (curves and straight lines without positioning units attached are removed). Elements starting with a `J` are `Joins`, `D` depicts `Divides`, and `A` represents a special item, an `Arena` (two inputs, two outputs). Stadium-shaped nodes depict positioning units. + +```mermaid +graph LR + J5 --> A1 + D4 --> J4 + D3 --> P1([PU-MC-1]) --> J3 + D2 --> P2([PU-MC-2]) --> J3 --> J2 + D1 --> P3([PU-MC-3]) --> J2 --> J1 + A1 --> J1 --> D1 --> D2 --> D3 --> D4 --> P10([PU-IO-2]) --> J4 --> D5 --> J5 + A1 --> P100([PU-IO-1]) --> A1 + D5 --> P50([PU-Buffer]) --> J5 +``` + +In order to reduce computational complexity for the PDDL solver, an even more simplified topology is computed that only contains the positioning units and leaves out all intermediate elements. The edge weight of the graph corresponds to the physical track length between the positioning units and is converted into seconds based on an assumed average speed of 0.56 m/s. + +```mermaid +graph LR + P1 & P2 & P3 & P10 & P50 --> P100([PU-IO-1]) + P1 & P2 & P3 & P10 & P100 --> P50([PU-Buffer]) + P1 & P2 & P3 & P50 & P100 --> P10([PU-IO-2]) + P1 & P2 & P10 & P50 & P100 --> P3([PU-MC-3]) + P1 & P3 & P10 & P50 & P100 --> P2([PU-MC-2]) + P2 & P3 & P10 & P50 & P100 --> P1([PU-MC-1]) +``` + +For each "positioning unit connection" two init statements are created: one that states that these two positioning units are connected with each other (`TransportationNodeConnection`), and another one setting the function value for the function `shuttle-time`, representing the estimated traveling time in seconds between these two positioning units. The resulting PDDL init statements are listed below: + + +```pddl +(:init + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 25) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 30) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 54) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 78) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 37) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 25) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 35) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 59) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 83) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 42) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 28) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 33) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 62) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 86) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 45) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 30) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 35) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 40) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 26) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-Buffer E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 47) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 18) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 23) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 28) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 52) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-1 E_PositioningUnit-IO-2) 36) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-3) 51) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-2) 56) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-MachiningCenter-1) 61) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-Buffer) 22) + (TransportationNodeConnection E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) + (= (shuttle-time E_PositioningUnit-IO-2 E_PositioningUnit-IO-1) 47) +) +``` + +## Material Assembly Information +Information about what material can be assembled from what other material is captured from the `assembly` relation in the `MaterialClass` and `MaterialDefinition` instances. + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class OpenTopBlackYellowBlue + <> OpenTopBlackYellowBlue + class ChassisBlack + <> ChassisBlack + class CabinYellow + <> CabinYellow + class BodyOpenTopBlue + <> BodyOpenTopBlue + OpenTopBlackYellowBlue --> BodyOpenTopBlue : assembled from + OpenTopBlackYellowBlue --> CabinYellow : assembled from + OpenTopBlackYellowBlue --> ChassisBlack : assembled from +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:init + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MD_Chassis-Black) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MD_Cabin-Yellow) + (MaterialDefinitionAssembly MD_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue MD_Body-OpenTop-Blue) +) +``` + +Information about the current assembly state are expressed through the assembly relation of the `MaterialLot` relation. This is not only used to express the current state, but also for the formulation of goal statements, es depicted below. The `from` IEC 62264 model is extracted from the [goal description model](../iec62264/CIIRC-Testbed-TASE-Goal-1.iec62264). + +From + +```mermaid +classDiagram + class OpenTopBlackYellowBlue1 + <> OpenTopBlackYellowBlue1 + class ChassisBlack1 + <> ChassisBlack1 + class CabinYellow1 + <> CabinYellow1 + class BodyOpenTopBlue1 + <> BodyOpenTopBlue1 + OpenTopBlackYellowBlue1 --> BodyOpenTopBlue1 : assembled from + OpenTopBlackYellowBlue1 --> CabinYellow1 : assembled from + OpenTopBlackYellowBlue1 --> ChassisBlack1 : assembled from +``` + +to + +```pddl +(:goal + (and + (MaterialLotAssembly ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_Body-OpenTop-Blue-1) + (MaterialLotAssembly ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_Cabin-Yellow-1) + (MaterialLotAssembly ML_OpenTop-Black-Yellow-Blue-1 ML_Chassis-Black-1) + ) +) +```